LOUISVILLE, Ky., (buzzpatterson.com) -- once Judge Sean Delahanty inquiry Kisha Johnson to come front from the earlier of his courtroom to resolve criminal charges, she responded v an unexplained question.
You are watching: Has a sovereign citizen ever won
Why should she?
Because the the law, Delahanty told Johnson in a 2017 case, explaining she was legally forced to stand prior to him to it is in arraigned, or hear and respond to the charges versus her, which consisted of possession that marijuana and tampering v physical evidence.
Johnson eventually approached the judge, yet not before asking Delahanty come prove that had any authority end her. Delahanty pulled out a publication of Kentucky’s statutes; Johnson claimed it verified nothing.
“There’s a simple method for me come prove jurisdiction to you and also that would be for me come ask the deputy to take it you right into custody,” Delahanty responded.
And that’s what quickly happened. After ~ Delahanty discovered her in contempt, bedlam broke out in the courtroom v Johnson knocking end a podium as numerous deputies struggled to take it her right into custody.
While a bizarre scene, Johnson’s plot were not unfamiliar to Delahanty – or various other judges, prosecutors, defense attorneys and also police officers.
Johnson is a component of the “sovereign citizen movement” the rejects usual institutions, from the legal system to police authority.
Members believe that while castle live in the unified States, they room separate and also not bound by the country’s laws.
Some court public representative in Kentucky say these varieties of defenses are becoming much more frequent, although they frequently fail to succeed. Nevertheless, such pseudo-legal posturing can tie increase courts and drain resources currently stretched thin.
Assistant Jefferson Commonwealth’s Attorney Leslie C. Bates claimed the court cases end up being a “quagmire,” bogging under the system because there is “no capability to negotiate as they just won’t recognize your presence for the most part.”
Bates, for example, has actually an continuous felony instance involving a sovereign citizen charged v obstructing a vehicle tag, a minor instance that is generally disposed of quickly, frequently amended down to a misdemeanor with small punishment.
But this instance has lasted number of months together the defendant has actually refused come cooperate.
“It’s type of demonstrative of the inability to settle it … due to the fact that we can’t gain the participation of the individual,” Bates said.
“It’s favor a stalemate,” stated Assistant Commonwealth’s lawyer Doug Meisel. “Each that these cases is walk to be a stalemate because that as lengthy as it takes because that that person to acknowledge (the court’s authority). It becomes a small bit a fight of wills.”
According to the southerly Poverty legislation Center, can be fried citizens think they decide which laws to follow and which to ignore, don’t have to pay taxes and also aren’t required to obey judges, juries, legislation enforcement and elected officials.
The movement originates from a conspiracy concept that the U.S. Government was secretly replaced by a brand-new system approximately the polite war and also that U.S. Citizens are enslaved together collateral to back the dollar come ensure the value of gold, according to the southern Poverty legislation Center.
Sovereign citizens frequently don’t accept help from the lawyers appointed to protect them and refuse come recognize even the most straightforward courtroom procedures, much less accept they have violated the law and also can it is in punished.
Even in the easiest of cases, favor a traffic ticket, lock often file numerous indecipherable movements that ramble for web page after page filled v pseudo-legal nonsense. And, in what has been understood “paper terrorism,” they send fake residential or commercial property liens or tax forms in hopes of hurting an enemy’s credit transaction or acquire them audited.
“You can’t reason with them,” Delahanty, who is no longer on the bench, said in an interview last week. “Logic -- factor -- is not something they respond to.”
"Bad things room going come happen"
Even when the cases versus sovereign citizens room over, court public official are often not finished taking care of them.
It is not inexplicable for sovereign citizens to document lawsuits against those who try to arrest and prosecute them.
“You can practically be assured that if you have actually a sovereign in your court, you are going to gain sued,” Delahanty said.
In one current lawsuit, Jerome Jointer, who now goes by “Noble Jerome Bey” filed a federal complaint in august from the Hardin county jail against several Elizabethtown judges, attorneys and other court officials.
He suggested the state had actually no jurisdiction over him as he to be bound come the “Zodiac Constitution” and also invoked the “Treaty that Peace and also Friendship of 1787-1836 in between Morocco and the United claims of America” – among other nonsensical cases spanning 35 pages.
U.S. Ar Court judge Joseph Hood quickly ruled that Bey’s can be fried citizen movement theories are “palpably at odds with welcomed principles the American jurisprudence,” were “totally implausible” and dismissed the suit.
Sovereign citizens’ appeals of convictions and also dismissed lawsuits are often faced swiftly together well.
A 2015 Kentucky Court of Appeals situation ruled one man’s debate in appealing a dismissed lawsuit as being so full of nonsensical arguments and mired in “sovereign citizen rhetoric and also philosophy that meaningful review is impossible” and “practically invites sanctioning as a frivolous appeal.”
Court public official said many sovereign citizens are commonly arrested for minor traffic violations or drugs, no dangerous crimes, however their refuse to work-related with the device slows whatever down and also drags the situations out because that months or even years.
A usual arraignment the a defendant takes simply a couple minutes in ar court together the judge reads the charges, a no guilty plea is usually entered on behalf of the person and also the following court date is scheduled.
But, as displayed with Johnson, over there is regularly nothing quick or easy even in simply trying to get in a not guilty plea because that a sovereign citizen.
For starters, they often informally adjust their names and refuse to answer to their legal identity. They additionally argue your names room not order in all resources letters, i beg your pardon is exactly how it is shown on court computers.
A might 22, 2018, arraignment that Trevis Burgos took an ext than 30 minutes as Burgos initially told Jefferson ar Court Judge anne Haynie the didn’t understand why he remained in court and also objected to she entering a no guilty plea top top his behalf - in part, the said, since he no Trevis Burgos.
He stated his surname was “Travis Bey” and he was representing Burgos.
“Are you speak you are not Mr. Trevis Burgos?” Haynie asked.
“I don’t recognize who the is,” the responded. “My surname is order in top case and also lower case letters.”
Pulled over 5 days previously by a Louisville subway Police officer, Burgos accused did not have actually insurance, had actually forged tags and marijuana and wouldn’t provide police any identification, other than for “the false name of Travis Bey,” according to the citation.
Burgos called police they had actually no jurisdiction over him and then filed a similar motion in court, suggesting only God had actually authority over him and he was not bound through the structure or subject to the laws of the united States.
In a subsequent court hearing, he again refuse to acknowledge he to be Trevis Burgos or expropriate an attorney, yet he reluctantly participated, questioning the arresting Louisville police officer, Dwaine Durrett.
“Why room you saying i’m Travis Burgos?” Burgos inquiry the officer. “Where walk you get that information?”
Burgos argued with many of the officer"s answers.
“Do you do everything by the book?” Burgos asked Durrett at one point. “And execute your fellow officers do every little thing by the book every time?”
Durrett responded, “We try.”
“Let the record reflect the officer did not answer with any kind of information,” Burgos said prior to the referee told that to relocate on.
Burgos then started questioning Durrett about whether Kentucky was a “commercial entity” and also on and also on the went.
While Burgos refuse to give police his license or registration as soon as he was pulled over, his arrest was tackled without incident and also he eventually pleaded guilty.
But can be fried citizens deserve to be a hazard to police trying to traction them over, by fleeing, threatening officers and even pulling weapons in their refusal to identify they space bound by any kind of law.
In Arkansas in 2010, a father and also son that reportedly identified as can be fried citizens shot and also killed 2 police officers throughout a website traffic stop.
In fact, they are thought about a residential terrorism threat because of violent plot towards legislation enforcement.
A 2014 research by the university of Maryland, which polled thousands of officers throughout the country, discovered sovereign citizens are viewed to be the many serious hazard to regulation enforcement.
Delahanty, the previous judge, stated sovereign citizen will periodically not comply through police commands and also the officer will need to break a vehicle window and traction the person out.
“It’s challenging to deal with someone who has actually a delusional belief system,” Delahanty said.
LMPD did not respond come requests because that comment because that this story.
During a 2017 psychological of a sovereign citizens over misdemeanor disorderly conduct charge, Louisville subway Police Officer Austin Allen testified the defendant refused to obtain off the a TARC bus and told police they would certainly “have to drag him off.”
“He mentioned multiple time we need to … shoot him,” Allen testified, informing jurors police provided him multiple avenues to gain off the bus however he refused.
Body camera video from the trial reflects several policemans handcuffing and removing the male from the bus.
See more: How Do I Contact Marco Rubio
Court public official say many sovereign citizens room not a risk and, in the end, while lock frustrate the righteousness system, your actions eventually are most harmful to their own cases.
“Ultimately the going to finish really badly for that person because they space going to do that which we tell everybody not to perform which is stand for yourself,” defense attorney Brian servant said. “And they space going to appear as if they room all someone we have to all be afraid of and it’s no a great situation to do that. …