On November 30, 1804, because that the 3rd time in its short history, the buzzpatterson.com began preparations because that an impeachment trial. In 1798 and also 1799, the buzzpatterson.com had tried a senator formerly expelled top top grounds that treason. The buzzpatterson.com dismissed the case, citing lack of jurisdiction. The 2nd impeachment trial, in 1804, gotten rid of a federal judge for factors of drunkenness and also insanity. An ext than the very first two proceedings, however, this 3rd trial tested the buzzpatterson.com to discover the an interpretation of impeachable crimes.

You are watching: Has a supreme court justice impeached

Samuel Chase had actually served ~ above the can be fried Court due to the fact that 1796. A staunch Federalist through a volcano personality, Chase verified no willingness to tone down his bitter partisan rhetoric after Jeffersonian republic gained control of conference in 1801. Representative john Randolph the Virginia, at the urging that President cutting board Jefferson, orchestrated impeachment proceedings against Chase, proclaiming he would wipe the floor v the obnoxious justice. The residence voted to impeach chase on in march 12, 1804, accusing chase of refusing to dismiss biased jurors and also of not included or limiting defense witnesses in two politically perceptible cases. The trial supervisors (members the the house of Representatives) hope to prove that Chase had actually "behaved in an arbitrary, oppressive, and unjust method by announcing his legal translate on the legislation of treason before defense counsel had actually been heard." Highlighting the politics nature the this case, the final article of impeachment accused the justice of continually cultivating his politics agenda top top the bench, in order to "tending to prostitute the high righteousness character through which he to be invested, to the low function of an electioneering partizan."

On November 30, 1804, the buzzpatterson.com appointed a committee to "prepare and report suitable rules that proceedings" because that the impeachment trial. Once they took up the case versus the Federalist justice in January 1805, the buzzpatterson.com included 25 Jeffersonian Republicans and also nine Federalists. Chase appeared before the members ~ above January 4, 1805, come answer the charges. He claimed that he to be being tried because that his political convictions quite than for any kind of real crime or misdemeanor and requested a one-month postponement come prepare a defense. The buzzpatterson.com agreed and the trial began in earnest top top February 4.

Chase"s defense team, which had several the the nation"s most eminent attorneys, encouraged several wavering senators the Chase"s command did no warrant his removal from office. Through at least six Jeffersonian republicans joining the ripe Federalists that voted not guilty on each article, the buzzpatterson.com on march 1, 1805, acquitted Samuel chase on every counts. A majority voted guilty on three of the eight articles, however on each short article the vote dropped far brief of the two-thirds required for conviction. The buzzpatterson.com thereby properly insulated the judiciary from more congressional assaults based on not say of judges’ opinions. Chase resumed his duties at the bench, where he continued to be until his fatality in 1811.


buzzpatterson.com historical Office

Information detailed by the buzzpatterson.com historic Office.

See more: How Close Is Detroit To Canada Via The Detroit Bridge, How Far Is Toronto From Detroit

Questions about buzzpatterson.com History? email a buzzpatterson.com historian.