In this article: 10yearsin, blu ray, Blu-Ray, bluray, editorial, style war, formatwar, hd dvd, hdpostcross, ps3, sony, sony blu-ray player, sonyblu-rayplayer, toshiba, video, xbox 360

The layout war. End the last few decades it has actually played out across various creates of tech -- AC vs. DC, VHS vs. Beta -- usually with fierce fight lines drawn and millions, or even billions, that dollars in ~ stake. Recently, no one has shed so brightly as the battle of HD DVD vs. Blu-ray (read our blow-by-blow retrospective of the 2005-2007 fight here). And it carried all the standard elements: Sides were divided in between titans of the industry, led through Sony pushing the Blu-ray side and Toshiba backing HD DVD, with the PS3 and Xbox 360 all set to serve as Trojan horses. As if the comb weren"t high sufficient already, the specter of one oncoming internet-streaming winter loomed prefer Game of Throne"s military of White Walkers. For this reason what really happened? that won in the end? And, many importantly, was that success actually worth it all?


Looking ago to 2005, HDTVs were finally accessible everywhere, yet not everyone had one yet. A study by Leichtman Research team would put the fostering rate at around 12 percent by the finish of the year, and Nintendo even decreased to do an HD-ready variation of its brand-new game system, the Wii. The was practically impossible to buy movies in high definition, with cable or satellite broadcasts left as the only easy options. DVD player-based upscaling promised to do movies look better on HDTVs, however couldn"t fairly compare with the resolution the the actual thing. There was a irradiate on the horizon, however: Sony and also Microsoft were both all set to ar calculated bets on the "HD Era" the gaming, and also the PS3 would also arrive with a Blu-ray player built-in. Microsoft stuck with plain DVDs, but promised an HD DVD add-on for the future.

You are watching: Hd dvd player vs blu ray


The Competitors: Sony vs. Toshiba

On one side, Sony promised the Blu-ray format could handle volume (50GB) and even interaction (BD-J) that we"d never ever seen before. When Toshiba declared HD DVD could consist of the void in volume (30GB max) and modern technology by gift cheaper and also easier come manufacture v plants that were already making DVDs. Together for content, significant studio assistance weighed heavily in Blu-ray"s favor, whereas only Universal was standing in HD DVD"s corner. I hedged my bets by purchase both the HD DVD add-on for the Xbox 360 (it to be bundled with Heroes season one -- a decision ns stand by) and a PS3. Considering the content advantage, it"s yes, really no surprised that HD DVD failed, as the only viable alternate was some type of hybrid push that integrated Blu-ray. The was a space both LG and Samsung tried and failed to close v hybrid players. Warner Bros. Thought about making a play because that the room with expensive dual-sided discs, yet never actually put them top top sale.

And the winner is...


Once Warner Bros. Dropped assistance for HD DVD ~ above the eve of CES 2008, the war was over. Sony had properly pushed Blu-ray right into millions of residences with that is PS3 Trojan horse; this, despite trailing Xbox 360 and Wii in sales throughout the at an early stage days of the console war. Effectively, it to be Sony"s decision to do HD discs typical for the PS3, together opposed to an optional add-on, that resulted in a hardware void HD DVD might never surmount. Include in the overwhelming studio support on the Blu-ray side, and it"s clean in retrospect that only stubbornness (and a couple of contractual obligations) retained things walking as long as they did. Toshiba threw in the towel just over a month after ~ Warner Bros." CES announcement, and the fledgling HD DVD library was rendered obsolete; currently mere collector"s items because that a scant few.

The price that success


So to the victor go the spoils, right? no quite. When Sony"s Blu-ray layout prevailed, it never ever quite turned into the cash cow its backers originally predicted. Blu-ray quiet hasn"t unseated DVD together the main physical movie-delivery format, and also it"s gift squeezed out of relevance on the other end by the increase of video clip on-demand and also streaming. This year, Sony took a $240 million hit since of "demand because that physical media contracting faster than expected," something that"s not helping its recurring attempts to destruction out that a massive financial hole. It might be worse though, as Toshiba is experiencing the indignity of marketing Blu-ray players of its own and also facing the same declining PC and also TV sales that have actually hit and also crippled Sony.

LG and also Samsung took a different technique to the format war with (token) do the efforts to assistance both sides and, by shifting emphasis to mobile, the 2 companies have actually seen far-ranging growth. Microsoft fail to check out the HDi interactive technology it added to HD DVD record on, however its Xbox 360 led the video game console sales charts because that years -- and also never once, despite numerous rumors, showed up with an internal HD DVD drive. Microsoft likewise jumped top top the Netflix streaming fad early in 2008 before even the PS3 and also Wii scored access. Now, the Xbox One plays games and movies alike from Blu-ray discs, come go together with cable TV hooks and also streaming apps, and also it"s almost not weird.

Despite year of rumors it would certainly jump right into the style war, Apple never ever did, and never has. The ran the other way, greatly ditching support for optical discs ~ above its machines and to this day, it still doesn"t make a Blu-ray journey for Macs. Its iTunes video clip on-demand store is a leader in digital movie sales, and also the to apologize TV hockey puck has ridden a increasing tide for streaming boxes come sales of end $1 billion last year. Net movie services and also connected devices are rising promptly in popularity, with Netflix topping 40 million subscribers and also Google"s Chromecast dongle marketing "millions" the units.


Sony"s win has actually its benefits though, and also the firm has certainly turned things approximately with the playstations 4. The console hasn"t ushered in a new format, yet it"s enjoying a sales lead that continues to grow. The PS4"s likewise built through an eye come the future: Sony"s hosting a beta regimen (PlayStation Now) for streaming games and also promising one internet-delivered TV service later this year, adding to the Blu-ray movie playback and healthy suite that streaming video clip apps.

Blu-ray isn"t prepared to be composed off either, as disc sales proceed to grow slowly, and also studios pack in digital duplicates to increase their appeal. The advent of Ultra HD could additionally be a bonus, as execs have told united state a spec bang is being discussed.

So what did us -- the consumers who actually buy every this stuff -- get?

Unfortunately, the format war separated content for exclusives and also caused studios come stagger movie rollouts. Partly as a result, also now, some classics (or cult classics) are either quiet unavailable in HD or are just hitting shelves. Also, copy protection is both together tight as ever, and as ineffective. Movies space consistently easily accessible as rips at or prior to their key release. And even the PS4 calls for a workaround just to enable video clip capture for games, amongst other DRM headaches. While schemes favor digital copies and Ultraviolet have listed some portability, promised features (managed copy) have actually never arrived and moving content past the bowl is still far more complex than it must be.

See more: Hillary Sold Uranium To Russia Fact Check, The Alternative 'Russia Scandal'


On the other hand, we were promised a movie suffer at house that lastly truly rivaled what"s accessible in theaters, and also I think that bar has been met. The streaming press is pass set-top boxes that support more than one service, but that doesn"t typical the job of the video format war space over; they"ve just adjusted battlegrounds. Every delivery organization (e.g., Netflix, Amazon, Hulu, cable TV) has actually its very own exclusive content, and it"s practically impossible to obtain them all in one ar -- v the amount of money in ~ risk, it appears we"ll never learn a different means to execute this.