Then-Secretary that State and also U.S. Sen. Ron Johnson, R-Wis., greeted each various other prior to a Senate committee hear on Jan. 23, 2013 in this Reuters photo.

You are watching: Hillary benghazi testimony what difference does it make


If the buildup doesn’t disappoint, you can expect many of news out of the U.S. Home Oversight Committee hearing on might 8, 2013.

The panel will certainly review exactly how President Barack Obama’s administration -- including then-Secretary the State Hillary Clinton -- taken on the Sept. 11, 2012 bombing at the U.S. Consulate in Benghzai, Libya.

The assault killed four Americans -- and collection off management critics such as U.S. Sen. Ron Johnson, R-Wis.

A few days prior to the hearing, it to be disclosed the a top U.S. Diplomat had actually said "everyone" in ~ the consulate assumed "from the beginning" the the assault was an act of terror.

And even prior to that, Johnson had actually reminded citizens at the very least twice the what Clinton called him about the assault during a Senate committee hear in January 2013.

"Was it since of a protest or was it since of men out because that a to walk one night and decided they’d go kill some Americans," Clinton said. "What difference – in ~ this point, what distinction does that make?"

So that was the punch-line quote. But what to be the context?

With Benghazi earlier in the news and also renewed attention being payment to Clinton's comment, we believed this would certainly be a good time for In Context, an occasional attribute that provides context come statements that obtain widespread notice.

Based on a C-SPAN video of their six-minute exchange, right here is a transcript that what Johnson and Clinton said throughout the Senate international Relations Committee hearing on Jan. 23, 2013:

Johnson: give thanks to you, Mr. Chairman and also Madam Secretary. I'd prefer to join my partner in thanking you for your business sincerely, and also appreciate the truth that you’re below testifying and also glad the you’re feather in great health.

Clinton: say thanks to you.

Johnson: to be you completely aware in actual time -- and also again, ns realize how big your job is and also everything is erupting in the center East at this time -- were you totally aware of these 20 incidents that to be reported in the ARB in actual time?

Clinton: i was aware of the ones that were lugged to my attention. They were part of our ongoing discussion around the deteriorating threat atmosphere in east Libya. We definitely were an extremely conscious that them. I was assured by our security professionals that repairs were under way, added security upgrades had actually taken place.

Johnson: give thanks to you. Go you view personally the cable on -- I believe it to be August 12th -- specifically asking for, basically, reinforcements for the security detail that to be going to it is in evacuating or leaving in August? did you see that personally?

Clinton: No, sir.

Johnson: OK. When you read the ARB, that strikes me as how details the human being were the the assaults started in ~ 9:40 Benghazi time. As soon as was the very first time you speak to -- or have actually you ever talked to -- the returnees, the evacuees? Did you personally speak come those folks?

Clinton: I‘ve spoken to among them, however I waited till after the ARB had done that is investigation due to the fact that I go not desire there to be anybody raising any issue that i had spoken to anyone prior to the ARB performed its investigation.

Johnson: exactly how many people were evacuated indigenous Libya?

Clinton: Well, the numbers space a little bit tough to pen down due to the fact that of our other friends --

Johnson: Approximately?

Clinton: Approximately, 25 come 30.

Johnson: did anybody in the State Department speak to those folks very shortly afterwards?

Clinton: there was discussion going top top afterwards, yet once the examination started, the FBI speak to them prior to we spoke to them, and so various other than our world in Tripoli -- which, ns think you’re talking about Washington, right?

Johnson: The suggest I’m making is, a very straightforward phone speak to to this individuals, i think, would’ve ascertained immediately that there was no protest prior to this. This assault started at 9:40 p.m. Benghazi time and it was an assault. I appreciate the truth that you referred to as it one assault. Yet I’m going ago to then-Ambassador Rice five days later going on the Sunday reflects and, what I would say, is purposefully misleading the American public. Why wasn’t that known? and again, I appreciate the reality that the transparency of this hearing, yet why weren’t we transparent come that allude in time?

Clinton: Well, an initial of all, Senator, I would certainly say that as soon as the assault happened, and once we got our world rescued and out, our many immediate issue was, number one, taking care of their injuries. Together I said, i still have a DS certified dealer at Walter Reed seriously injured -- getting them into Frankfurt, Ramstein to get taken care of, the FBI going over immediately to begin talking to them. Us did not think that was appropriate for united state to talk to them prior to the FBI performed their interviews. And also we did not -- i think this is accurate, teacher -- I certainly did not know of any type of reports that contradicted the IC talking points at the moment that Ambassador Rice went on the TV shows. And also you know I simply want to say that world have accused Ambassador Rice and also the management of misleading Americans. I deserve to say trying to it is in in the center of this and understanding what to be going on, nothing can be more from the truth. Was information developing? to be the case fluid? would we reach conclusions later on that weren’t got to initially? and I appreciate the --

Johnson: But, mam Secretary, execute you disagree v me that a straightforward phone speak to to those evacuees to identify what happened wouldn’t have ascertained immediately that there to be no protest? that was a item of information that can have been easily, conveniently obtained?

Clinton: But, Senator, again—

Johnson: in ~ hours, if not days?

Clinton: Senator, friend know, as soon as you’re in these positions, the last thing you want to carry out is interfere with any kind of other process going on, number one—

Johnson: ns realize that’s a great excuse.

Clinton: Well, no, it’s the fact. Number two, I would recommend extremely you review both what the ARB said around it and the divide ARB because, even today, there are concerns being raised. Now, we have actually no doubt they to be terrorists, they were militants, they assaulted us, they eliminated our people. However what to be going on and why they were doing what they were doing is still unknown --

Johnson: No, again, we were misled the there were supposedly protests and that other sprang out of the -- an assault sprang the end of that -- and also that was conveniently ascertained the that was no the fact, and the American people could have actually known that within days and also they didn’t recognize that.

See more: How Do I Contact Facebook Headquarters Information, Number To Facebook Headquarters

Clinton: With every due respect, the truth is us had 4 dead Americans. Was it because of a protest or to be it because of men out for a go one night who chose that they’d they walk kill part Americans? What distinction at this suggest does that make? it is our project to number out what happened and also do whatever we deserve to to stop it from ever happening again, Senator. Now, honestly, i will execute my ideal to answer her questions around this, however the truth is that world were make the efforts in actual time to acquire to the finest information. The IC has actually a process, ns understand, going through the various other committees to explain how these talking points come out. But you know, to it is in clear, it is, from mine perspective, less essential today spring backwards as to why this militants chose they go it 보다 to find them and also bring them to justice, and then maybe we’ll number out what was going top top in the meantime.