What’s through Hillary’s mrs Problem?

Feminists want much more than the White home now—and that’s trouble for the very first female nominee.

You are watching: Hillary clinton is not a feminist


For Clinton, gift the an initial woman in the White House—one that the feminist movement’s main goals for decades—would be in part ways just the start: The genuine test would certainly be how totally her agenda meets the demands of a feminist base the is regularly in disagreement.

Clinton would not walk right into the Oval Office with built-in support from young woman voters, who have grown increase outperforming guys in the classroom and seeing women as their professors and also doctors (not to point out senators and governors). Her very own wealth and also race additionally undermine she appeal: simply as americans are significantly nonwhite, so too space feminists; just as being gay, lesbian, bisexual or transgender is increasingly normalized, so too space LGBT folks an ext visible and also vocal in feminist activism. Because that young women, feminism today have to take into account all of these constituencies and also elevate the voices that the many marginalized. For all the obstacles she’s faced due to the fact that of she gender, Clinton is not completely representative of a broad movement in which numerous women find their particular experiences shaped by your gender and their race and also their class, or some various other combination.


Nor carry out all American women watch a Hillary Clinton presidency in particular as promising because that feminist policy. Her really real accomplishments as a feminist—that well known 1995 Beijing speech as soon as she declared “women’s civil liberties are human being rights,” for one—were lengthy enough earlier that few younger voter remember them. Millennials may have been only elementary schoolers when Bill remained in office, however the less-than-feminist 1990s democratic policies—welfare reform, “safe, legal and also rare” abortion—are well-known, and deeply despised, by today’s young feminists. Few of us talked around it in women’s studies class. Others lived it, staying silent through shame after ending pregnancies or farming up through mothers that struggled to acquire by due to the fact that of those much-touted “welfare come work” provisions the cut aid to countless needy families.

Of course, Hillary is not Bill. And also she, along with the autonomous Party as a whole, appears to realize the today’s base has actually changed. Whether thanks to her very own inclinations or to push from younger feminists (not to cite the woman economists, think-tank and also nonprofit leaders, lawyers and also young staffers on she campaign), Clinton has adopted the many feminist agenda of any nominee in history, helping to normalize the idea the feminism together a major pillar of policy. Even Trump’s daughter Ivanka feeling obliged come pepper her speech at the Republican nationwide Convention through standard feminist plan fare, from equal pay because that equal occupational to the prestige of trusted child care.

In 2016, abortion as “safe, legal and rare” is no more; Clinton not only wants to store it safe and also legal, but also publicly opposes the Hyde Amendment, i beg your pardon blocks commonwealth Medicaid dollars from spanning abortion like any other form of health and wellness care. When Clinton was on record opposing Hyde in 2008, she was quiet around it; this choice season, she’s voiced she opposition at rallies and campaign events. Meanwhile, her plan for government-supported child care is the many progressive and ambitious in a generation: universal pre-kindergarten for every 4-year-old, increased salaries because that child care workers, child treatment scholarships because that student-parents, expanded funding for on-campus child care centers, and a cap on middle- and low-income families’ child treatment spending. It might not resonate with the college-educated girls viewer that is most likely to delay childbirth into her 30s, but the mean American woman without a college degree gives birth before she hits 25. Because that her, this would certainly be a video game changer—and, provided that gender-based revenue gaps room exacerbated once women have actually children, perhaps a an excellent equalizer.


If Clinton can obtain these and other female-friendly plans passed into law, countless feminists will cheer. Yet others will definitely say it’s also little, particularly when she makes the inevitable political compromises. With every policy proposal Clinton puts forth and every invoice she signs, she will have to answer not simply to her party and also the American people, but to women: Is this regulation feminist enough? Is she looking out for the most marginalized women? does this do injury to any group that women? One load of being the very first woman is the expectations space outsized, and, together a result, disappointments space greater and also judgments space harsher.

Oddly, and lamentably, what could most hold together feminists in a Clinton presidency is the ongoing fight, underscored by Albright, Dunham and also Steinem, for basic respect for females in the public sphere—a struggle on full display in the sexist spectacle that this election season. The most evident examples come in the comically outsize misogyny on see at trump card rallies, native supporters and also from the candidate himself: stickers reading “Life’s a bitch. Don’t vote for one,” T-shirts billing Trump as “finally someone with balls,” crowds shouting, “Lock her up!” together they did in ~ the GOP convention, a tame chant compared to the “kill her” mantra therefore regularly, and also loudly, intoned in ~ the Republican candidate’s gatherings. Climate there are the much subtler indignities and prejudices she has actually faced. Clinton is too loud and also sounds as well combative, male commentators say. She constantly inquiry why she’s not likable (a concern few seem to have around Trump). She told she requirements to laugh more.


The buzzpatterson.com 50

Our guide to the thinkers, doers and also visionaries transforming American national politics in 2016.

See more: How Did John Lennon And Paul Mccartney Meet & What Did They Think?

If anything deserve to unite women, sad come say, it might be this sort of crass sexism. Climate again, Clinton has a well-documented propensity to drive defensive, and that might turn off the young ladies she still demands to convert. All of this place tremendous pressure on Clinton. After all, winning the White house is hardly the finish of the road. Simply one mrs can’t usher in the revolution by herself.