Conservatives have exploited the life and also legacy of ar organizer Saul Alinsky in a bid to demonize Hillary Clinton, but they misrepresent his yes, really influence and also writings.

You are watching: Hillary clinton letter to saul alinsky

Forty-seven years after she graduated from Wellesley College, Hillary Clinton is still having actually to defend her senior thesis.

That"s since right-wing activists and also their media allies space assailing Clinton"s research document on Saul Alinsky, a vital figure in the civilization of community organizing whom conservatives have labeled a attention radical and also a diabolical affect on both Barack Obama and also Clinton.

Ben Carson kicked turn off the Saul Alinsky hatefest top top the second night of this year"s Republican convention in Cleveland, declaring throughout his primetime speech: "Now, one of the things that I have actually learned around Hillary Clinton is that one of her heroes, she mentors, was Saul Alinsky. And her senior thesis was around Saul Alinsky. This was someone she significantly admired and let me tell you something about Saul Alinsky."

Alinsky "wrote a book called Rules because that Radicals," Carson continued. "It acknowledges Lucifer, the original radical who gained his very own kingdom. Now think around that. This is our country where our establishing document, the declaration of Independence, talks about certain inalienable civil liberties that come from ours creator, a nation where ours Pledge the Allegiance says we are "One nation under God." This is a country where every coin in our pockets and every bill in ours wallet says, "In God we Trust." So room we ready to selected someone as president who has actually as their function model somebody who acknowledges Lucifer? Think around that."

Carson"s especially rhetorical contortion of link Clinton with Lucifer drew large and often critical media attention. But overlooked in the dispute was the larger story of how conservatives have actually twisted a little-known community organizer into a price of radical extremism. Operatives on the right have actually repeatedly invoked Alinksy to literally demonize both Clinton and also Obama. Conservatives" caricature the Alinsky misrepresents his ties to Obama and also Clinton, and bears tiny resemblance to his really life and work. Indeed, Alinsky"s gospel of self-reliance could strike a chord with numerous on the right. And even some Tea Party activists have borrowed from Alinksy"s organizing playbook-though the hasn"t stopped them from using him to smear Clinton.

Consider Carson"s inflammatory Lucifer comparison. Alinsky"s Rules for Radicals, written in 1971, opens up with blurbs around three figures-Lucifer, Jewish religious leader Rabbi Hillel, and Thomas Paine. He described Lucifer together "the first radical known to guy who rebelled against the establishment and also did the so effectively that that at least won his own kingdom."

That"s the only cite of Lucifer in the entire book.

It wasn"t intended as an endorsement of Satanism, yet as a comment about the long tradition in history of dissent and protest.

Carson took extr liberties through the truth by identifying Alinsky as Clinton"s "role model." Hilton Rodham-who was college student body president at Wellesley, graduating in 1969-did indeed write her senior thesis about, and also interviewed, the controversial activist. But she was actually quite an essential of Alinsky"s views.

Summarizing her 92-page political science thesis, ""There Is only the Fight": An analysis of the Alinsky Model," The New York Times observed:

Ms. Rodham endorsed Mr. Alinsky" s main critique of federal government antipoverty programs-that they often tended to be also top-down and removed from the wishes of individuals. Yet the student leader break-up with Mr. Alinsky over a main point. The vowed come "rub raw the sores of discontent" and compel action through agitation. This, she believed, ran respond to to the concept of change within the system.

In 2003, while she to be a U.S. Councilor from brand-new York, Clinton discussed Alinsky in she memoir, Living History. Clinton "agreed with several of Alinsky"s ideas, an especially the worth of empowering civilization to aid themselves," she wrote. "But we had actually a basic disagreement. He thought you could change the device only native the outside. Ns didn"t. Later, he offered me the opportunity to work-related with him as soon as I graduated from college, and also he was disappointed the I decided instead to go to law school. Alinsky stated I would be wasting mine time, yet my decision was an expression of my id that the system can be changed from within."

" src="" title="ap_764236668968.jpg.jpe">

Despite Clinton"s critique of the controversial activist, we have the right to expect come hear much more about she ties to Alinsky in between now and November and, if she wins the White House, also after she takes office. That"s since America"s right-wingers are obsessed through Alinsky and invoke the in an effort to discredit Clinton, together they did with Obama.

ALTHOUGH ALINSKY passed away IN 1972, that casts a long shadow thanks to his reputation together a tough-talking, street-smart agitator who assisted poor and also working-class Americans acquire a voice in battles through politicians and also corporations.

Obama to be constantly struck for his claimed allegiance to Alinsky throughout his two campaigns for president, and also throughout his presidency. Conservatives pointed come Obama"s 3 years together a young ar organizer in Chicago in the 1980s together proof the he shared Alinsky"s left-wing views. In 2008, Rudy Giuliani declared on Meet the Press the Obama had been recruited to organize in Chicago through "a Saul Alinsky group" v "a really core Saul Alinsky kind of almost socialist notion that should be provided for redistribution of wealth."

In fact, the group that recruited Obama, the developing Communities job on Chicago"s southern side, to be not affiliated v the Alinsky-founded Industrial areas Foundation, yet with the Gamaliel Foundation, a network the church-based groups. Throughout his stint as an organizer, Obama absolutely was familiar with Alinsky"s ideas, yet he left the organizing human being after three years because, prefer Hillary Clinton, he short the appetite for confrontation and believed he can make more large-scale influence by getting a law degree and also entering tendency politics.

During the critical month of the 2008 campaign, when it looked together though Obama to be going to win, a parade of conservative commentators, talk display hosts, columnists, GOP operatives, and politicians broadened their orchestrated assault on Obama"s community-organizing experience and his affinity through Alinsky, in a bid to smear the autonomous candidate as exterior the cultural and politics mainstream.

For example, a Byron York National Review pillar that questioned just how Obama"s neighborhood organizing qualified him to be chairman dwelled heavily on Alinsky.

After Obama gone into the White House, Fox News" glen Beck, radio hold Rush Limbaugh, and other reactionary pundits constantly attached him to Alinsky, whom they actors as a Marxist machiavellians whose principles for radical readjust had infiltrated the democratic Party. In 2009, the right-wing writer David Horowitz released a 37-page pamphlet licensed has been granted Barack Obama"s Rules for Revolution: The Alinsky Model. The covering featured 4 photos-of karl Marx, Vladimir Lenin, Alinsky, and also Obama-to show Obama"s purported intellectual roots.

During a segment referred to as "What is the Connection between Obama and also Saul Alinsky?," bill O"Reilly called his Fox News audience the Obama was an Alinsky acolyte "in the good tradition of knife Marx Lenin."

On the show, commentator Monica Crowley stated, incorrectly, that Alinsky had committed Rules because that Radicals to Lucifer (he dedicated it come his wife) and (wrong again) the Obama had "actually taught Alinsky 101 together a course" in ~ the college of Chicago.

"This is the really essence that socialism," Crowley warned. "The tactics of Saul Alinsky and also Barack Obama room geared towards wealth redistribution."

On a special Fox news segment hosted by Sean Hannity, "The real Obama: The Alinsky Connection," conservative writer Ben Shapiro said Obama ran his management like one Alinsky-style organizer, which, that said, "means radical change in extreme left direction."

During his own primary project for president the year, Newt Gingrich continually invoked Alinsky"s ghost to assault Obama.

" src="" title="david_horowitz_by_gage_skidmore.jpg.jpe">

"The centerpiece of this campaign, i believe, is American exceptionalism matches the radicalism of Saul Alinsky," Gingrich claimed in stump speeches and also television appearances. Or variously, "If you think as we perform in the statements of Independence and also you think that"s a much better source 보다 Saul Alinsky, welcome come the team." Gingrich likewise claimed the Obama "believes in a type of Saul Alinsky radicalism, i beg your pardon would cause a secular europe socialist model."

Robert Knight, a columnist because that the conservative Washington Times claimed that in Chicago, Obama was exposed come "the ruthless tactics and contempt for truth expounded by his guiding light, Saul Alinsky." In National Review, John fund wrote that Obama"s management was complying with the "Alinsky playbook." The white superior blog website WorldNetDaily asserted the Alinsky to be Obama"s "mentor" and that Obama to be Alinsky"s "star student"-ignoring the truth that Obama was 11 years old when Alinsky died.

CONSERVATIVES TRIED come TAR Hillary Clinton with the Alinsky connection when she was first Lady. In his 1996 biography, The Seduction that Hillary Rodham, David Brock-at the moment a Clinton hater yet now a Clinton friend-called she "Alinsky"s daughter."

When she ran versus Obama because that the democratic Party nomination in 2008, the right additionally attacked her as another Alinsky devotee. In 2014, as she geared as much as run again, conservatives started rehearsing their arrangement to produce a controversy around her allegedly extremist left-wing views.

In July 2014, conservative pundit dinesh D"Souza, appearing on ABC"s This Week come tout his documentary film, America: Imagine The human being Without Her, said that "there actually is a leg connecting Hillary come Barack, and also that bridge is Saul Alinsky."

Clinton"s enemies thought they"d uncovered a cigarette smoking gun when, in September 2014, the conservative Washington cost-free Beacon published a letter Clinton had written come Alinsky in July 1971 after her second year in ~ Yale regulation School, when she was working as a summer intern at the steady law for sure of Treuhaft, Walker, and Burnstein in Oakland, California.

In the letter-which reporter Alana Goodman found deep in the university of Texas archives-Clinton asked Alinsky when his new book (Rules because that Radicals) would certainly be comes out. She likewise referred come "encouraging words" that Alinsky had actually written her the previous spring when Clinton had moderated a campus conflict over even if it is Yale students should sign up with an anti-war to win in solution to Richard Nixon"s intrusion of Cambodia.

Clinton told Alinsky, "You are being rediscovered again as the brand-new Left–type politicos are finally beginning to think seriously around the hard work and mechanics of organizing." She created that she"d reap meeting through Alinsky if he involved the only Area.

The Free Beacon story quickly went viral within the right-wing echo chamber. However the short article left the end the critical sentence in Clinton"s letter: "Hopefully we deserve to have a an excellent argument at some time in the future." Clinton clearly was no less critical of Alinsky 보다 she had been in her Wellesley thesis. Nevertheless, the right-wingers regarded the letter as "gotcha" evidence that even in law school-and, by implication, throughout she life-Clinton to be still one Alinsky adherent.

" src="" title="hillary_clinton_lorain_2008.jpg.jpe">

Conservative websites told readers "New created Correspondence Revealed in between Hillary Clinton and also America-Hating Marxist Saul Alinsky" and also "Hillary Clinton"s letters to Communist Saul Alinsky Matter, and also the Media will certainly Bury Them." A headline on the right-wing FrontPage website screamed "Hillary will certainly Be Alinsky"s third Term: The Radical Plot to damage America Continues."

In a September 2014 National Review article around the letters, Stanley Kurtz-author of Radical-in-Chief: Barack Obama and the Untold Story that American Socialism-claimed: "Ever the Alinskyite, Hillary prefers to achieve leftist end incrementally, in pragmatic guise. It"s a conflict of method rather than ends, the same dispute that leads many leftists come doubt Obama"s ideological credentials, when in truth the chairman is as much a man of the left as ever."

During its Texas Weekend meeting in Dallas in June 2015, the conservative Freedom facility invited Kurtz to define "Hillary"s Alinsky Ties."

His talk, posted on the FrontPage website, called Clinton an "Alinsky-ite" that "has to be reluctant to present her true ideology system colors." But, Kurtz charged, "the hyper-leftist autonomous Party in the period of Obama is ultimately forcing Hillary to be who she"s been every along. It"s liberating her from her Alinsky-ite disguise."

Now that she"s to be the democratic nominee, we deserve to expect the anti-Alinsky roar to prosper louder, and also to try to do the surname Alinsky an epithet, as evidenced by Carson"s rant likening Clinton to Lucifer.

Through super PAC–sponsored ads, media conduits, and also Trump surrogates like Carson and Gingrich, Republican strategists will certainly make sure that voters consistently hear Clinton"s surname tied to Alinsky"s. They can count on the truth that most Americans have actually never heard that Alinsky. He"s a little-known figure, with a vaguely foreign-sounding (and Jewish-sounding) name, exploited by conservative who explain him together a radical and also socialist and also then pen him to Clinton, just as they tried to connect him to Obama.

BUT ALINSKY"S STORY IS hardly a mystery. He"s to be the topic of one major biography (Sanford Horwitt"s Let Them call Me Rebel, published in 1989) and of a full-length 1999 documentary film, The democratic Promise, narrated by Alec Baldwin.

Lost in the proxy battle over Alinsky is any sense of that he yes, really was, what he did, and also what the believed.

Yes, Alinsky was a street-smart rabble-rouser. However anyone familiar with him would have actually a tough time squaring his patriotism and passion because that democracy through the devilish extremist that conservatives make him the end to be.

Born in 1909 to Orthodox Jewish parents who divorced when he to be 13, Alinsky grew up in a Chicago slum. In ~ the college of Chicago, that took process in the school"s famed sociology department and then attend graduate courses in criminology and law. Leave graduate college without a degree, he joined Chicago"s Institute because that Juvenile research (IJR), which was occurring community projects based on the then-novel theory that crime is the result of poverty and also social chaos in neighborhoods. Alinsky occurred a talent for building trusting relationships with ar residents, criminals, and prisoners.

In 1938, IJR assigned Alinsky to study Chicago"s earlier of the Yards area, the immigrant community of about 90,000 made famous in Upton Sinclair"s novel The Jungle. Alinsky spent many of his time through leaders of the Packinghouse workers union, that were trying to organize employees of the major meat-packing firms that conquered the area. The union interpreted that it would be challenging to victory a success in the workplaces without neighborhood support, for this reason they taken on Alinsky"s initiatives to develop a community organization.

Alinsky reshaped work in America by carrying grassroots-organizing tactics from shop floors and factories come urban areas and spiritual congregations. In back of the Yards, that sought out local leaders involved in churches, sporting activities leagues, ar businesses, and also other social networks. One was Joseph Meegan, a super of recreation at Davis Park. He and Alinsky acquired the confidence of Chicago"s auxiliary Catholic Bishop boy name Sheil, who founded the Catholic Youth Organization. Sheil aided them recruitment young priests and parish leaders, and to get over the tensions between Catholics from different ethnic backgrounds. Alinsky and also Meegan convinced Sheil to speak in ~ the 1939 founding meeting of the earlier of the Yards community Council (BYNC), i beg your pardon comprised around 75 organizations, including unions, neighborhood groups, churches, sports clubs, and small businesses. The following day, Sheil mutual the stage with job leader man L. Lewis, president of the congress of commercial Organizations, in ~ a rally that 10,000 people.

The alliance between the church and also the union guarantee that the BYNC would certainly be taken serious by the city"s political and also corporate power-brokers. BYNC pressured city officials to carry out the community with institution lunch and milk programs, fluoridated drink water, an infant-health clinic, and also a baseball field with floodlights. BYNC gained the city to clean increase vacant lots, and it sold garbage cans to the community at a fraction of the industry cost. BYNC started a credit transaction union to provide local residents and businesses v low-interest loans, and pressured the federal works Progress administration and the nationwide Youth administration programs to provide jobs for ar residents. These successes significant the start of modern community organizing.

BYNC also caught the fist of vital patrons. Bishop Sheil and also Marshall field III (a newspaper publisher and also heir come his family"s department store fortune) helped money Alinsky"s brand-new organization, the industrial Areas foundation (IAF), which collection out come train neighborhood organizers and also build community organizations in other cities. In 1946, Alinsky published Reveille for Radicals, a bestseller that explained the nuts and bolts of effective organizing. The book ended up being the holy bible of neighborhood organizing till he created his next book, Rules because that Radicals, in 1971.

Alinsky"s publications not only noted organizers through a toolkit that principles and tactics, but likewise offered a vision for a revitalized democracy. Alinsky was scornful of society workers, who he believed viewed negative people as "clients" come be served by beneficent experts. He felt likewise about government anti-poverty programs, which he referred to as "political pornography" because he believed they spread crumbs the kept civilization pacified.

"We learn, when we respect the dignity of the people, the they can not be denied the elementary best to participate fully in the options to their own problems," Alinsky composed in Rules because that Radicals. "Self-respect arises just out of human being who play an active role in resolving their own crises and also who space not helpless, passive, puppet-like recipients of private or public services. To give civilization help, if denying them a far-ranging part in the action, contributes nothing come the advance of the individual."

THE ORGANIZER"S JOB, Alinsky argued, is to agitate world to identify their very own self-interest and then assist them mobilize to an obstacle the bastions the power and privilege. Organizers have to show human being that countless problems they see as personal troubles have the right to only be resolved through cumulative action.

Alinsky taught the confrontation and conflict to be often important to readjust power relations. He believed it was crucial to "rub raw the resentments that the people in the community." that meant gaining people associated in small-scale war (against unscrupulous vendors or realtors, because that example) so they might experience winning, gain self-confidence, and then tackle bigger targets and issues. Community organizing, he believed, taught civilization how to win concrete win through an imaginative tactics that were fun and morale-building.

Yet he recognized that compromise is the love of democracy. "To the organizer," he composed in Rules because that Radicals, "compromise is a an essential and beautiful word. That is always present in the pragmatics that operation. … If you start with nothing, need 100 percent, then compromise for 30 percent, you"re 30 percent ahead."

Alinsky viewed his success in Chicago as a an initial step in building a network the "people"s organizations" around the country. That envisioned this groups, in addition to unions, forming the communication of a gradual movement for social justice. In 1947, Alinsky rental Fred Ross, an proficient organizer in California"s Latino community. Ross developed the Community business Organization in several cities, mostly amongst Latinos, recruiting new members and also identifying potential leaders through house meetings and also one-on-one conversations. In mountain Jose, among the people Ross recruited was Cesar Chavez, who Ross hired and trained as an organizer. Chavez would certainly later embrace these organizing ideas in starting the unified Farm workers union.

" src="" title="ap_6704250106.jpg.jpe">

In the mid-1960s, Alinsky started training organizers and also overseeing projects in Buffalo, new York City, St. Paul, Kansas City, and Chicago. That worked very closely with african American teams in major cities, hoping to construct stable organizations that could battle segregation and also wield influence on a selection of fronts.

After riots erupted in Rochester"s black color ghetto in the summer of 1964, an interracial group of priest members inquiry Alinsky to aid them start building a strength base among low-income african Americans to difficulty the city"s leading employer, Eastman Kodak, i m sorry employed just 750 blacks the end of 40,000 employees. (Alinsky quipped the "the only thing Kodak has actually done on the race problem in America is to introduce shade film.")

After numerous months that meetings, local residents started Freedom, Integration, God, Honor, now (FIGHT), a community-organizing group, to take on Kodak. Once the agency refused to produce a training and hiring regimen for black color residents, hit upped the ante. A variety of FIGHT members and their churches purchased Kodak stock and also pledged to to visit the company"s yearly shareholder meeting. Kodak make the efforts to keep protesters at a distance by hold the meeting in Flemington, brand-new Jersey, however FIGHT carried 1,000 people more than 300 miles to the meeting. Their activity gained national media attention.

Next, Alinsky intimidated to bring 100 black human being to a Rochester Philharmonic Orchestra concert after dealing with them to a banquet of nothing but vast portions of small beans. The idea to be to command the nation"s an initial "fart-in" come embarrass Kodak, a significant Philharmonic sponsor. Fortunately for the Philharmonic, struggle never had to resort to that tactic, due to the fact that Kodak agreed come implement the tasks program.

The fight in Rochester was usual of Alinsky"s approach, which to be to employ any tactic the would job-related to bring an effective politicians and also corporations come the negotiating table with plain people. Together he created in Rules for Radicals, "The Prince was composed by Machiavelli because that the Haves on just how to host power. Rules for Radicals is written for the Have-Nots on exactly how to take it it away."

After the Detroit riots in 1967, Michigan governor George Romney, a middle Republican, was in search of ways to enhance race relations and give black occupants a bigger stake in the state"s political and economic system. That year-according come T. George Harris"s 1968 biography, Romney"s Way-he met v Alinsky to ask his advice around addressing the city"s post-riots gyeongju turmoil.

"I think you must listen come Alinsky," Romney advised his political allies. "It seems to me that we are always talking to the exact same people. Maybe the time has pertained to hear brand-new voices."

When this anecdote surfaced 4 years earlier on the right-wing blogosphere, conspiracy-minded extremists offered it as evidence that Romney"s son, Mitt-who was then to run for the GOP presidential nomination-had been infected by the Alinsky virus.

Despite the titles of his books, Alinsky was a reformer, no a revolutionary. Throughout the 1960s, Alinsky was particularly scornful of the student brand-new Left and also the campus anti-war movement. He believed that they relied too much on protests, demonstrations, and also media celebrities, and did not understand the prestige of structure organizations. He also considered your rhetoric silly, utopian, dogmatic, and alienating to their potential working-class base. He to be fond the quoting James Madison, cutting board Jefferson, and Paine. He taken into consideration himself a patriotic American.

Alinsky eschewed ideology. His closest political ties were to the Catholic Church. He commonly spoke at seminaries, advising future priests to put Catholic society teachings right into practice by helping to organize your parishioners instead of doling the end charity. In 1969, a coalition that Catholic groups provided Alinsky the Pacem in Terris Peace and also Freedom Award, named after Pope john XXIII"s encyclical ~ above war, peace, and also social justice.

Alinsky"s principles took hold and also influenced organizers and activists roughly the country. His books and colorful campaigns brought him a good deal of fist (including a glow profile in Time newspaper in 1970), and he ended up being an top figure among organizers, even after he died in 1972.

At the time, America was suffering an upsurge of community organizing. Countless emerging activist groups embraced some of Alinsky"s ideas. They organized with part success approximately slum housing and also tenants" rights, publicly safety, and also racial discrimination by banks, well-known as redlining. Ecological organizations attracted on Alinsky"s ideas, too, particularly those fighting the building of nuclear strength plants and also the industrial poisoning of their neighborhoods, as in the Love Canal Superfund disaster in Niagara Falls, brand-new York.

See more: How Do You Say 2 In Chinese, How To Say Numbers In Chinese

Today, plenty of of the community-organizing groups that follow Alinsky"s concepts are rooted in religious congregations that constitute a progressive counterpoint come surging right-wing activism among evangelicals.

But the left has no syndicate on making use of Alinsky"s techniques. After Obama take it office in 2009, even as the Tea Party and also conservatives choose Glenn Beck assaulted Obama for being an Alinsky-ite and a "socialist," they started using Alinsky"s publications as training devices to construct a right-wing movement. Flexibility Works, a corporate-funded conservative group started by former Republican congressman dick Armey, provided Rules because that Radicals together a primer because that its training of Tea Party activists. Tea Party leader man O"Hara explained that "Alinsky"s book is important since there really is no equivalent book for conservatives. There"s no "Rules for Counter-Radicals.""

One the Alinsky"s "rules" to be to "Pick the target, frozen it, personalize it, and also polarize it." clearly in its efforts to demonize Hillary Clinton as an Alinsky disciple, the right, and also now the trumped campaign, have learned a lot native the organizer"s playbook-even as they misrepresent his really legacy.