“Do i contradict myself? really well, ns contradict myself.” So claimed Walt Whitman. Hillary Clinton’s critics say she shifts she positions for political convenience. She fans say the development of her views reflects that she listens and also learns. Either way, over there are far-reaching differences in between Secretary that State Clinton, candidate Clinton, and also what we could expect native a chairman Clinton. These 5 facts detail those differences.

You are watching: Hillary clinton views on foreign affairs

1. Iraq War

Criticism of Clinton’s foreign policy invariably begins before her tenure as the Obama administration’s lead diplomat. Clinton, along with 76 various other senators, poll in favor of the Iraq battle in 2002. The small senator from new York, Clinton would eventually worry a mea culpa in a 2014 memoir: “I assumed I had actually acted in great faith and made the finest decision I might with the details I had. And also I wasn’t alone in acquiring it wrong. However I still gained it wrong. Plain and simple.”


Read More: accomplish the southern African Politician Who’s Been compared to Barack Obama—But Prefers invoice Clinton

And if Clinton was sold a bill of goods, so were the American people: 56 percent that Americans want to invade Iraq earlier in October 2002. Yet, numerous Democrats proceed to treat she politically convenient vote for the war as the original sin the her international policy career—and she politically practically renunciation that it as equally suspect.

(Gallup)

2. Center East

In fact, Clinton has actually hawkish tendencies the can’t it is in denied. Once Obama started drawing under troops in Iraq, Secretary Clinton want to leaving behind a residual pressure of 10,000-20,000 American troops. She supported the surge in Afghanistan in 2009, and argued for intervention in Libya in concert with the French to oust Muammar Qaddafi.

But the Middle east is no doing well these days—which pipeline Clinton in a bind. Candidate Clinton requirements to project strength and also toughness because that a fear electorate without more alienating those on the left that don’t to trust her. You don’t get much room because that error as soon as your unfavorable rating is at 57 percent. And while Secretary Clinton make the case for forceful intervention in Syria the Obama would at some point rebuff, that worry isn’t beneficial for her: Syria makes Obama look bad, and she really requirements his help (and the reflected glow that his 56 percent approval rating, follow to a current poll). But if she becomes President Clinton, you have the right to expect an ext active engagement in the region, happen the U.S. Back in the direction of its traditional tendency toward treatment in the center East’s security emergencies.

(New York buzzpatterson.coms, Gallup, abc News)

Read More: exactly how the Obama change Could ache Hillary Clinton

3. Russia

As Secretary that State, Clinton spearheaded America’s “reset” with Russia to combine diplomatic relations and spur better cooperation across a organize of issues, consisting of counterterrorism and also nuclear proliferation. In fact, the new Strategic arms Reduction treaty (START) shepherded follow me by Clinton would location a ceiling of 1,550 nuclear warheads because that both the U.S. And also Russia, a significant drop compared to start I’s border of 6,000.

But beneath the surface, there was small Clinton can do to warmth the forever frosty U.S.-Russia relationship. By the buzzpatterson.com Vladimir Putin ordered troops into Crimea in 2014, Clinton to be ramping up her presidential campaign and also likening Putin’s floor grab to “what Hitler did earlier in the ’30s.” as a candidate, she’s said forcefully for checking Russian aggression, however how a president Clinton would certainly respond to that aggression depends on what Putin walk next. It’s likewise worth questioning how crucial U.S. And Russian relations really are? economically speaking, Russia is simply the U.S.’s 24th largest importer and doesn’t even crack its top 30 exporters. Washington and also Moscow can share details on terrorist threats. They can communicate with one an additional to ensure their contending interests don’t inflict unnecessary collateral damage. However it’s tough to imagine what pressure could bring the U.S. And also Russia together as friendly partners.


(Brookings, U.S. Census Bureau)

Read More: Chelsea Clinton Would think about a ‘Daughters Summit’ v Ivanka Trump

4. China

Clinton’s most ambitious plan while at State to be the renowned “pivot come Asia,” the long-term strategic realignment that U.S. Interests towards the Pacific in i beg your pardon she played a top role. Clinton famously took trip to Beijing as very first Lady ago in 1995 and delivered blunt criticism of the country’s person rights record. Yet by 2009, Clinton to be wondering great “how do you transaction toughly v your bank,” recognizing the secretaries of state have less leeway come lecture 보다 presidential spouses—especially as soon as the nation they represent owes the various other $1.46 trillion. Yet, together a presidential candidate, Clinton has returned to pugnacious form, accusing the Chinese government of “trying come hack into every little thing that doesn’t move,” even if the criticism is intended greatly to narrow any kind of electoral benefit Donald Trump might gain native talking tough on China.

Still, China has come to be too crucial to the an international economy and also a functioning human being order because that a president Clinton to take on anything yet a cautious and also pragmatic approach.

(US Treasury Department)

5. Trans-Pacific Partnership

But if China to represent Clinton’s propensity toward pragmatism, the other component the the Asia pivot—the Trans-Pacific partnership (TPP)—represents her willingness to cavern under heavy political pressure. TPP was an alleged to it is in a main part of Barack Obama’s presidential legacy. Instead, it’s come to be a lightning rod for controversy as trumped rides nativist bluster and also “America First” protectionism come the last runoff for the U.S. Presidency. Have to TPP pass, the would attach the U.S. V 11 asian countries (excluding China), uniting 40 percent of the world’s GDP together in a solitary comprehensive profession deal.

Clinton was a element architect that TPP, and also spent year touting that is virtues and necessity. Yet faced v a farming protectionist backlash—some 53 percent of americans now think that totally free trade kills much more jobs 보다 it creates—Clinton has actually retreated behind the paper-thin refrain that “I carry out not at this buzzpatterson.com support it together it is written.” Tim Kaine—Clinton’s VP pick—was likewise a support of TPP till this week, whereby he dropped in line behind the Clinton campaign message.

See more: Housewives Of Orange County New Season 16? Rhoc Season 16 News & Updates: Everything We Know


The truth of national politics in America this particular day is that the job determines the motive. The Secretary that State wants to construct a solid foreign policy; the candidate desires to get elected; the chairman is commander-in-chief and must respond come the human being as the is—not simply through diplomacy but somebuzzpatterson.coms with the credible threat of force. Clinton is nothing if not a career politician, and also her changing views on foreign policy reflects that. It will certainly be up to voters come decide how her technique compares through the foreign policy vision put forward by she aggressive and also outspoken opponent.