From Haiti to Syria, the democratic candidate’s lengthy record says she’s looking forward to gift a war president on job one.

You are watching: Hillary clinton voted for iraq war


*
*

an initial Lady that the joined States, Hillary Clinton and her daughter, Chelsea visit U.S. Troops in ~ Tuzla waiting Base, Bosnia and Herzegovina, 25th march 1996. (Photo by )

Whoever is elected on Nov. 8 will be a war president on work one, v the power and also autonomy to undertake destabilizing reflects of force, drone strikes, special operations raids and ever-deepening military interventions. Today, combat convoy deployments are frequently made by executive branch spokespeople, decision to back open-ended air battles in locations like Yemen by “partners” like Saudi Arabia are announced via press release, and congressional monitor hearings greatly boil down to legislators pleading with commanders come ask for an ext troops and looser rules of engagement.

And much of this more than likely suits Hillary Clinton simply fine.

Unlike Donald Trump, who has wildly moving positions and alleged “secret” plan to defeat the Islamic State, Clinton has considerable track record upon which one have the right to evaluate her likely positions. By any kind of reasonable measure, Clinton qualifies as a hawk, if a nuanced one. Despite she has actually opposed uses of pressure that she believed were a bad idea, she has actually consistently endorsed starting new wars and expanding others.


Whoever is chosen on Nov. 8 will be a battle president on job one, through the power and also autonomy to undertake destabilizing mirrors of force, drone strikes, distinct operations raids and ever-deepening military interventions. Today, combat troop deployments are frequently made by executive branch spokespeople, decision to ago open-ended air battles in areas like Yemen through “partners” favor Saudi Arabia are announced via push release, and congressional monitor hearings largely boil down to legislators pleading with commanders to ask for much more troops and looser rule of engagement.

And much of this more than likely suits Hillary Clinton just fine.

Unlike Donald Trump, who has wildly moving positions and also alleged “secret” to plan to loss the Islamic State, Clinton has substantial track record upon i beg your pardon one can evaluate her likely positions. By any kind of reasonable measure, Clinton qualifies together a hawk, if a nuanced one. Despite she has opposed provides of force that she thought were a negative idea, she has actually consistently endorsed starting new wars and also expanding others.

Consider 7 prominent cases in i m sorry she has had actually to decide whether to support the use of American armed forces force:

Haiti: In 1994, Clinton protest intervening in Haiti come reinstate the Jean-Bertrand Aristide government. As chronicler Taylor Branch recounted in his diary the interviews with Bill Clinton: “I asked that what Hillary thought. He claimed the pell-mell rush to attack was stunner to her. Reacting against the pressure, the absence of options, and his sense of being trapped, she said he was badly served by his international policy staff.” This was an astute referee by the then-first lady, together the options developed by the U.S. Southern Command and Joint Chiefs were poorly conceived and also often logistically difficult to lug out. Fortunately, a 25,000 U.S. Troop intrusion was avoided after Jimmy Carter brokered a last-minute agreement with Raoul Cédras the assured the would action down indigenous power.

Iraq: In 2002, together a councilor for new York, Clinton voted for the authorization for the usage of military force in Iraq. In her accompanying floor statement, she asserted it to be to ensure chairman George W. Shrub was “in the strongest possible position to lead our nation in the United nations or in war” and to present Saddam Hussein that the nation was united. After initially defending the vote, she later adjusted, variously proclaiming she “thought it to be a poll to placed inspectors earlier in,” it to be “based ~ above the facts and assurances that I had at the time,” and ultimately “it to be a failure to to trust Bush.” Clinton also justified the 2002 vote as simply one for compelling compliance, proclaiming, “I think in coercive diplomacy,” in a January 2008 presidential debate. Regardless of the factors or sorry behind she vote, the Iraq war was a foreign-policy and geopolitical disaster.

Pakistan: In 2007 and also 2008, Clinton strong disagreed through then-Sen. Barack Obama around striking al Qaeda targets inside of Pakistan. Obama referred to as such assaults “just typical sense” if there were “actionable intelligence.” Clinton referred to the 1998 cruise missile strikes in Afghanistan that failed to kill Osama bin Laden and warned that “we have to be really conscious of all the consequences,” an especially anything that would certainly destabilize Pakistan’s nuclear arsenal. Obama would certainly go on to authorize 407 drone strikes in Pakistan, death 3,089 people. Practically 300 of these developed while Clinton to be secretary the state, throughout which time U.S. Diplomats opposed only one or 2 of the strikes. Whatever hesitation Clinton once had actually in attacking militants in Pakistan vanished ~ above being shown as secretary of state.

Afghanistan: In 2009, Clinton sustained three-quarters the the Afghanistan surge. As soon as Gen. Stanley McChrystal, the commander of U.S. Pressures in Afghanistan, requested four brigades of added U.S. Troops in the summer the 2009, Clinton endorsed deploying 3 of them (equaling about 30,000 troops). Reportedly, “Clinton usually favored sending out even more 보다 entrances did.” Obama at some point deployed 33,000 extra troops. That is difficult to identify any enduring politics or defense gains in Afghanistan that have actually resulted indigenous the surge. Moreover, much more than three-quarters of every U.S. Convoy casualties in that country because 9/11 were eliminated or wounded in the four years ~ the surge to be initiated.

Libya: In 2011, Clinton was a solid proponent of regime adjust in Libya (as to be Trump). It is forgotten this day that a major justification she available for the U.S. Military function in Libya was to pay earlier allies for Afghanistan. Together she declared in so late March 2011: “We asked our allies, ours NATO allies, to go into Afghanistan with us 10 years ago. They have been there, and also a many them have been there regardless of the reality they were no attacked.… when it comes to Libya, we began hearing indigenous the U.K., France, Italy, various other of our NATO allies. This was in their vital national interest.” scholastic research reflects that an excellent powers enjoy liberty of activity to avoid coming to be dragged into wars entailing allies, but the Libya regime change intervention was, unfortunately, one the the Obama administration chose to completely support, in spite of misleading the American civilization at the time that the was no the goal. Obama correctly labeled no planning because that the postwar script his “worst mistake” and also correctly explained Libya as a “mess.”

Osama bin Laden: In 2011, she endorsed the navy SEAL raid into Abbottabad, Pakistan, that killed Osama bin Laden, even while recognizing that it would likely poison diplomatic relations with Pakistan because that a brief time. Follow to Vice chairman Joe Biden — that opposed it — every other main (including Clinton) was “51-49” in sustaining the raid. Before the news broke, Obama called Bill Clinton (who, as president, signed three concealed findings authorizing bin Laden’s killing) come let him understand the al Qaeda leader was finally dead. “I assume Hillary’s already told you,” Obama said to one unaware Clinton. As Hillary Clinton later on wrote in she memoir: “They called me no to call anyone, so ns didn’t tell anyone. Bill later on joked v me, ‘No one will ever doubt you can keep a secret!’”

Syria: In 2012, she apparently proposed come the White residence — along with CIA manager David Petraeus — a hidden program (apparently bigger than the one later authorized) to administer arms come vetted Syrian rebel groups fighting Bashar al-Assad’s government. Obama protest this proposal on the grounds that there can be no promises of where the weapons would ultimately finish up and that CIA analysts determined they would certainly not have actually “materially” quickened the removal of Assad indigenous power. That is an overwhelming to assess the CIA-led train-and-equip program’s effectiveness, compared to larger Defense Department-led efforts, but there stays no repertoire of U.S.-backed rebel groups that has actually threatened the existence of the Assad government, i beg your pardon is now backed by indiscriminate Russian air power.

Outside of certain interventions, Clinton also supported muscular reflects of pressure as secretary that state. New York Times reporter note Landler describes a July 2010 White residence debate around rerouting the USS George Washington aircraft carrier indigenous its regular cruise right into the Yellow Sea. Adm. Robert Willard, the head of U.S. Pacific Command; Adm. Mike Mullen, the chairman the the share Chiefs; and also Secretary the Defense gateways all i agree on this wild maneuver. “Clinton strongly seconded it. ‘We’ve acquired to run it increase the gut!’ she had said to her aides a few days earlier,” Landler writes. However Obama refused the request, declaring, “I don’t call audibles with aircraft carriers.” It bear noting the determining the aggressiveness through which the United claims conducts freedom of navigation operations in marine waters asserted by China will be a consequential call for the following president.

Finally, Clinton has had an unusual exposure come the armed forces from multiple civilian positions, which may make she far far better prepared to offer as commander in chief 보다 her husband remained in 1993, when he had actually a notoriously daunting start leading the military. As very first lady, Clinton was routinely exposed to military intervention debates among senior officials, consisting of over Haiti, Bosnia, and Afghanistan, and also later served six year on the Senate equipped Services Committee and also four together secretary the state. She additionally has arisen close relations with retired armed forces officers prefer Gen. Jack Keane, who has rarely watched a country that cannot be improved with U.S. Floor troops and also airstrikes. Together Bob Woodward composed of a 2009 meeting between the two to comment on the Afghan surge: “Clinton greeted Keane v a be affected by each other hug, astonishing Holbrooke because—and he need to know—Hillary rarely bear-hugged anyone.”

I have spoken about Clinton through a handful of military officers, climate stationed in Islamabad and Kabul, that were routinely affiliated in video clip teleconferences with her as secretary that state. Lock all explained her as being, by far, the best-prepared an elderly participant in meetings and also having read all the memos or briefing publications that were sent out as preparatory material. Castle relayed that Clinton has actually an intimate understanding of armed forces doctrine, Pentagon acronyms, and military plan principles and was not afraid to press an elderly commanders come clarify the “courses of action” and also the plan “end state” of any given armed forces intervention.

See more: Gypsy Rose Blanchard Crime Scene Photos, Photos: Blanchard Case

Should Hillary Clinton victory the White House, the unified States, currently at war for 15 years, would certainly be led through a president deep aware and comfortable through the military. It’s difficult to recognize which nationwide security crises she would be compelled to confront, that course. But those that vote for she should understand that she will strategy such situations with a lengthy track document of being generally supportive the initiating U.S. Military interventions and also expanding them.