Reps. Elijah Cummings (D-Md.) and Rep. Trey Gowdy (R-S.C.) sparred over Hillary Clinton's e-mails with Sidney Blumenthal throughout a 2015 hear on Benghazi. (AP)
There"s a lot that can and will be jammed right into Hillary Rodham Clinton"s work of testimony Thursday before the home committee investigating the 2012 attacks in Benghazi, Libya.

You are watching: Hillary clinton what difference does it matter


There will, the course, be some details about the catastrophic deaths and also known threats challenged by the americans killed. There will virtually certainly be some conversation of what was said before and after the attacks, when and why they were described as random events rather than acts the terrorism, and what Clinton believes sparked them. Clinton"s now-infamous private e-mail server will likewise likely obtain some time.


*
2021 Election: complete coverage and also analysisArrowRight


There will be much left unspoken the hangs in the air, too. This is just one that those moments where the specter of politics errors of both substance and also style loom large. An extremely large.


That"s why The deal with thought it wise to examine in through a pair of communications experts. Think about this guide to assessing what wake up Thursday.


Ruth Sherman is a political interactions consultant and also coach and former faculty member at the Yale university Women"s project School.Gordon Stables is a clinical professor that communication, director of debate and also forensics and also assistant dean at the university of southern California"s Annenberg college for Communication and Journalism. He specialization in political communication.

SHERMAN: Well, an initial off I would say the this is an additional opportunity the Hillary Clinton has to display that she can last. It"s a sad truth for women — especially enlarge women. But, they have tendency to be viewed negatively for numerous stupid reasons. For this reason if she can control to sit there and be conversational and focused without coming to be obviously irritated, if she is able to be high energy and ready for anything, it would certainly be come her advantage that will show world that she"s gained the vitality — and I dislike to use that native — to it is in president.


Clinton has an added burden. She has to help us imagine her in the Oval Office due to the fact that we haven’t had actually a woman in the presidency and also so, that’s difficult for some human being to imagine. That’s yes, really something us ask ourselves about all candidates, even subconsciously. It"s no right, yet that"s the method it is.


Second, ns think over there is an problem of proxemics right here — that"s an academic term for just how we use space. In this situation, there will be a committee sit on an elevated communication looking under on the audience and also the person providing testimony. That difference conveys authority. It says to anyone watching: The committee is important and deserving the answers and respect, even if Clinton does no actually respect them. However it can also lend itself to the committee, an especially the men on the committee, looking like bullies.


Finally, ns think she demands to come across as someone who feels badly, who thinks the this to be a disastrous thing the happened. She has to interact her humankind in this situation and also not just be a cold, calculating politician. This is an additional one of those areas where Clinton has an added burden that may not it is in fair yet can not simply be ignored. Socially, over there are, in every space, expectations the women will certainly be nurturing and kind and graceful.


STABLES: This is, choose it or not, the next big moment the political theater in the 2016 campaign. It"s a significant moment — one that will certainly likely have actually some substance but still crucial transition indigenous the debate for Clinton. Clinton had been in a an adverse spiral prior to the debate. The dispute reversed that. This hearing could proceed that or can mark a turn back toward the project in situation or battle stories the were the end there every summer. So a strong, credible performance yes, really matters here for Clinton.


And really, to be honest, ns don"t recognize that there has been another public figure who has actually spent so much time in the general public eye v so much criticism other than maybe Nixon. She’s not only been a politics figure however a lighting rod. There were Republican mailers sent out two decades ago come raise money turn off the danger of a Hillary Clinton presidency. Now that"s a actual possibility. However this is a hurdle Clinton needs to clear.


SHERMAN: She cannot appear evasive. That way redirecting, an altering the subject — and there can’t bee too lot whispering in the ear turn off mic, due to the fact that it will certainly all be analyzed as evasiveness. She need to avoid saying things like, "That’s an exciting point, but here’s what i think is much more important." that’s a an approach that a person can use in a situation where they space being request a question they would quite not answer. We understand that it"s a technique that deserve to work, in quick interviews. That works.


However, over the course of eight or nine hours, Clinton won"t have the ability to avoid plenty of subjects. It"s just not possible. If she do the efforts to often over the course of the day, it will certainly be noticed.


So, it goes practically without saying the this is usually not going to it is in a great place because that sarcasm. The only way — and I mean the only method — that she can successfully use sarcasm in this hear is if the committee somehow obviously goes end the top and also they punch it, if there space too many statements or assertions within concerns from the committee that have the right to be demonstrated as false, there might be part room over there to exhibit some sarcasm, or maybe also exasperation. But that"s one extremely an overwhelming decision she will need to make ~ above the spot, a an extremely tough and also delicate call.


When she last testified before, ns think, a Senate committee, she obtained exasperated. In ~ one point, "What distinction does that make?" came out. ns felt right there and then, that’s not the right answer. People died, let’s no forget, therefore that has to be treated through a an excellent deal that sensitivity.


She also has come be cautious not to overstep in the effort to disclose the committee as a partisan charade. I would certainly imagine the her surrogates will be out there act it for her, but I nothing think she must do it in ~ all throughout the hearing. It would weaken any type of statements that she makes.


STABLES: This hearing might go for up to eight hours. So, while she"s an experienced public speaker and also political combatant who is very composed in most settings, ns think that that won"t be basic to regulate in this setting. It is exceptionally hard for anyone to listen to what may be eight hours of criticism. Every day. Over and also over. That is really hard.


Plus, there"s already the narrative the end of the critical Benghazi hearing, i beg your pardon is the she shed her cool. So, this time, it"s going come be essential that she protect against that. She cannot carry out that again. That way not shaking she head in disagreement while others are talking, no murmuring, sighing or anything rather that can convey frustration or impatience.


For those city hall the hearings on TV, there will be a lot of separation screens and closeups of Clinton and also the various members that the committee. She can"t be caught making unusual encounters or dismissing anything said.


SHERMAN: Interestingly, lot like the committee, she has got to convey, constantly and also consistently, that she is there to phone call the truth, unvarnished. To perform that, she cannot, together she often does, look down or look away while talking. Eye contact is a wonderful means to assert you yourself in a nonverbal way.


She requirements to look and also sound favor someone who takes this process seriously. She have to sit forward, lean into — rather 보다 away from — the questions and also those doing the questioning. She have to speak in low, direct tones and bring her voice under at the finish of phrases.


She likewise has to it is in — I typical has to it is in — ready to answer questions about the e-mail servers, and also she won’t have a Sanders and his gift out there to intercede.


It will certainly be specifically important for Clinton come respond without too numerous delays or silences. Part silence have the right to be good to emphasize a point. But, when she is asked around events or e-mails or information connected on a particular date, it will certainly be challenging to mental those points immediately. For this reason she will, in ~ points, have to refer to her notes or rotate to her staff. When she walk that, she needs to be certain to say something follow me the lines of, "I want to be certain that i answer accurately, the I provide the committee the answer that deserves. So, permit me inspect my notes."


STABLES: If ns were helping her to prepare, I"d spend some time on gaining her to recognize her very own patterns, the ways that she communicates nonverbally that she is excited or tired or frustrated. For me, I tend to role my eyes. For this reason that"s other I have to shot to suppress.

See more: How Did John Kerry Make His Money, John Kerry: A 'Cheap' Aristocrat


So i think, in this case, i would also want to offer her some techniques to allow or appear relaxed or calm. Occasionally that"s as straightforward as a strategy to look in the direction the the committee while comment a inquiry or listening, yet actually concentrating on a room about 5 inches over a committee member"s head. That way, she deserve to really listen yet dedicate time come formulating she answer without showing up evasive or as if she is spring away and disengaged.