The novel Rodham imagines a near-real world where everything is different. Have the right to fantasy fictions assist us develop a ‘better future’ asks Caryn James.

You are watching: Hillary clinton will be the president

In 2016, the united state came so close to electing Hillary Clinton president, and Britain come so close come rejecting Brexit. What if things had gone differently? Creators of some of the finest recent novels and also television shows are creating alternate worlds based upon those tantalising what-ifs. Curtis Sittenfeld’s audacious brand-new novel, Rodham, imagines what Hillary Rodham"s life would have been like if she had actually not married bill Clinton. (Hint: she political ambitions kick in earlier.) Sci-fi understand William Gibson"s novel company is set partly in a people where Hillary is president and Brexit never ever happened. This season’s first instalment of the smart, politically-charged legal drama The good Fight (on CBS all Access) is collection during a Hillary Clinton presidency. The turned the end to it is in a character’s dream, yet it to be nice while the lasted.

More like this:

- just how dark stories have the right to comfort us

- The perfect TV show for now

- The prophetic writer who provided us hope

Other new counterfactual civilizations have a feminist slant, too. The underappreciated AppleTV+ series For every Mankind imagines what would have actually happened if the Russians had put a man and also then a woman on the moon before the US. All of sudden President Richard Nixon, not well-known to care around women’s rights, demands that the united state does the same. And no feminist fantasy is an ext trenchant than Margaret Atwood’s latest novel, The Testaments. A sequel come The Handmaid’s Tale, it takes us towards the downfall of the anti-woman state the Gilead.


Readers and viewers might be tired of acquainted dystopian fictions, especially since they have actually blurred right into reality. These brand-new works replace them with confident fantasies, solidly rooted in the real world. That is a simultaneous of timing they are landing in the middle of a global pandemic, but these counterfactual stories are potent reminders the how different today might have been.

Until now, alternating histories have most regularly been cautionary tales about a bleak, authoritarian future, with people War two a flashpoint. In HBO’s The Plot versus America, Charles Lindbergh is the fascist president of the US. In the Amazon collection Hunters, Al Pacino’s character leads Jewish Americans as they track down resurgent Nazis in the 1970s. And also Amazon’s The male in the High lock posits that Germany and Japan won the war. These series duty as warnings about our very own political dangers.

But 2016 sparked a various dynamic, perhaps since a non-Brexit world and a chairman Hillary Clinton were such near-misses, the results so shocking. It might be a stretch to imagine the the Nazis triumphed, yet we had already imagined a Brexit defeat and also a Clinton victory, pass these alternative histories close to home.

Sittenfeld’s novel is the most daring, as it takes us inside a fictitious Hillary’s mind and also uses a first-person voice. Gaining inside a living person’s head sounds choose a colossally poor idea, but Sittenfeld provides it convincing here, simply as she did with a personality based on an initial Lady Laura bush in her 2008 novel, American Wife. The very first stretch the Rodham rarely diverges indigenous Clinton’s life, while creating a psychologically astute portrait that appears as authentic and also revealing as any kind of non-fiction biography. Fiction provides us an intimacy that a factual portrait couldn’t, though. When Hillary and also Bill fulfill as idealistic students in ~ Yale law School, us feel your genuine mutual attraction, sexually and intellectually, in what the fictitious Hillary phone call a “swoony” romance. Bill is no the many faithful or ethical guy around, however we understand why she adheres to him to start a life together in Arkansas, where his political career begins.


That’s wherein the novel swerves. It doesn’t spoil lot to reveal that the alt-Hillary loses faith in Bill’s character, moves to Illinois and begins a stellar political career of her own. Even then, Sittenfeld shrewdly relies on real-life details, slightly skewed. “I mean I might have stayed home, small cookies, and also had teas,” she Hillary says during a project interview, repurposing the baking-cookies heat that produced a backlash because that the genuine Clinton. Her political enemies in the novel chant “Shut she up” at she rallies, a counterpart of the “Lock her up” cry at actual trump card rallies. As in the best alternating histories, this is completely believable. Sittenfeld has just one, droll, outsized fantasy. Donald Trump appears in the novel, no as a presidential candidate but as a reasonably harmless buffoon.

Gibson create a similar political shadow people in Agency, collection in two fictional timelines. One strand of the story is collection in post-apocalyptic London in the 22nd Century, where human being create so-called “stubs”, alternating realities. The other strand takes ar in a stub in san Francisco in 2017, when the Brexit vote and also the previous year’s presidential choice turned out differently due to “reduction in Russian manipulation of society media”. True to its sci-fi genre, company is primarily around artificial intelligence, and a young woman named Verity who is testing a new AI application in 2017. But for non-sci-fi fans, the social and also political backdrop is its many intriguing aspect.

Gibson’s 22nd-Century characters regard the alternating election and Brexit results as “positive change”, and no wonder. In their own time, parliament no longer exists and also they have withstood pandemics the the 2017 characters have not encountered (at the very least not yet). Published in January, firm was clear written prior to a pandemic was component of our daily lives. Gibson"s fiction now offers a clear-sighted reminder that plenty of scientists might see a disaster coming. Hillary Clinton is not called in Agency, but the female chairman is obviously her, under to the “Lock her up” graffiti in a restroom cubicle. Verity recalls a controversy in i beg your pardon the president’s the opposite candidate “loomed behind her”, and remembers “her very own sickened disbelief at his body language... His deliberate violation that his opponent’s politics space”. Verity’s memory might well it is in an account that the actual Trump-Clinton conflict a month prior to the election.


These near-real fantasies do not change dystopias through utopias, but with far better versions of the present. Agency’s fictitious president can’t restore peace in the center East. It’s enough that she averts one near disaster there. Over there is not also a utopia in the dream the the Hillary-supporting, Trump-hating attorney, Diane (Christine Baranski) in The good Fight. In her imaginary Clinton administration, cancer is cured. Yet due to the fact that Trump was not chosen there to be no Women’s in march in protest, and no #MeToo movement.

Butterfly effect

For every Mankind goes even further in illustrating the Butterfly Effect, the tradeoffs that can occur when one improved history is substituted because that factual events. The collection is one ambitious vision of an are exploration, v dramatic moon landings. The is likewise an absorbing an individual melodrama in i beg your pardon characters based upon historical figures exist together with fictional astronauts. It feels together realistic as anything in purely fact-based films, favor the Neil Armstrong biopic an initial Man.

Much the the plot in the ironically titled For every Mankind pertains to the fictitious American females who first go into space, in the beforehand 1970s, a decade before that actually happened. Yet the show emphasizes the difficulties behind their accomplishments. The trade-offs are worth it, yet the women battle with competitiveness, insecurity, and the toy fee on their relationships, not to cite rampant sexism. In this alt-world, Nixon loses his reelection campaign and also Ted Kennedy i do not care president. But as in The an excellent Fight, the far better presidency does no go smoothly. And the collection is haunted by deaths, some due to an are accidents, and also some just life ~ above Earth. 


A key work in this wider feminist pattern was The Testaments, released last autumn. Atwood is just the artist to change dystopian ideas with much more hopeful signs. ~ all, she created one the the most chilling dystopias ever before in The Handmaid’s story in 1985. The Republic of Gilead, v handmaids provided as sex-related slaves and baby factories because that commanders, was much more ominous than ever before by the time it ended up being a Hulu series in 2017, once women’s rights were significantly under attack. Atwood’s vision is still therefore disturbing, the hardly registers the the book’s epilogue, collection in 2195, discover Gilead to be an artifact from the past.

It’s all the an ext persuasive, then, that she provides a glimmer of positive outlook in The Testaments, through a trajectory moving from darkness to light. The main activity is set 15 years after the first novel, with Gilead on the cusp the falling. The novel’s three narrators incorporate the horrendous Aunt Lydia, a willing tool of the opening male leaders. She is covertly writing one account of her past, complete of regrets, and is plotting to aid the various other two narrators – young women, one raised in Gilead and the other part of that is Mayday resistance – escape come Canada with proof of Gilead’s crimes and also corruption.

Lydia now realises just how Gilead came to be possible. She and the rest of the populace ignored indicators of a wrong climate and also society. We should have paid attention, she says, to “the floods, the fires, the tornadoes, the hurricanes... The tanking economy, the joblessness”. How familiar is that? In recognising the danger that comes from obliviousness, Atwood points us towards a far better future, earned v the ordeals her characters have weathered.

Being optimistic is not virtually enough, though. Ryan Murphy’s Netflix collection Hollywood, i m sorry imagines what might have happened if the movie industry had overcome every its racist, homophobic, sexist biases back in the 1940s, could be a instance study in how not to produce an alternating history. The glamorous collection is compulsively watchable, also with the howlingly negative dialogue and also over-the-top acting. However awfulness might be the least of that problems.

It glibly reconstructs a previous in which a black color woman stars in a struggle movie and also wins one Oscar. The movie’s gay, black color screenwriter wins one too. For this reason does its Asian-American director. It’s together if Murphy waved a magic wand, and any roadblocks based on race or sex disappeared. Hollywood is all about fantasies, but this one has less link to reality than any type of fairy tale, wherein the heroes need to struggle to conquer obstacles.


The bold new alternate backgrounds are not saying that we can time travel backwards and also prevent a virus, remove bias, or turning back the Brexit fallout. Wernher von Braun, the real-life scientist, claims in a fictitious scene in For every Mankind, “Every political device is flawed and also every bureaucracy is corrupt”. This fictions take on such hard-nosed realism. They also deliver welcome scenarios because that this moment. If we can imagine a different past, flawed though it might be, we space that much closer to developing a far better future.

Love film and TV? Join culture Film and also TV Club on Facebook, a neighborhood for cinephiles almost everywhere the world.

See more: How Do You Find Out If Your Husband Is Cheating ? 10 Tech Clues To Find Evidence

If girlfriend would like to comment on this story or anything else you have seen top top Culture, head end to our Facebook page or article us on Twitter.

And if you preferred this story, sign up because that the weekly attributes newsletter, dubbed The vital List. A handpicked selection of stories from Future, Culture, Worklife and Travel, delivered to her inbox every Friday