Giant impacts could explain the numerous differences between the ice cream giants of ours solar system, computer simulations show.

You are watching: How are neptune and uranus similar


The Voyager 2 mission photographed the two ice giants, Uranus (left) and Neptune (right). (Credit: Left: NASA/JPL-Caltech; Right: NASA)
The ice giant planets Uranus and also Neptune seem like they need to look the same. Castle have similar masses, sizes and distances native the sun, and also scientists long thought they created in a comparable way. However we need only look at them to watch that the 2 planets room obviously different. It's one indication they could not it is in as similar as they it seems to be ~ at first blush.

Instead, each ice giant might have skilled its very own unique, traumatic occasion at some point in the past, putting them top top two various evolutionary tracks. And also in order to produce a an ext complete photo of exactly how the beforehand solar device formed, scientists need to know exactly how our outermost planets pertained to be.

Now, a team the researchers has actually used computer simulations to display that collisions v large, rocky bodies might have brought about the two planets’ diverging histories, possibly explaining why lock look so different.

See more: How Did Shailene Woodley And Aaron Rodgers Meet, How Did Shailene Woodley, Aaron Rodgers Meet

Ice huge Differences

Perhaps the most noticeable difference between the ice giants is their rotation angles. The turn of the earth Uranus is tilted by about 98 degrees contrasted to its orbital plane. Meanwhile, Neptune and also most the the solar system's other planets have rotations that are more or much less aligned v their orbits (though Venus similarly rotates the "wrong" way).

The 2 ice giants have actually other significant differences, too, prefer the fact that Neptune seems to have some heat resource warming it from the inside, if Uranus more than likely does not.

Past researches have argued that huge impacts could explain the tilted rotate of Uranus, while also accounting for other differences between the ice giants. So Christian Reinhardt of the college of Zurich and other researchers determined to test whether today’s modern 3D simulations would support these ideas. 

Two type of Collisions

The researchers found that if Neptune experienced a head-on collision through some huge rocky human body in the past, it might have deposited part extra power deep within the world that's been gradually seeping out as warmth over time. This, castle think, can be the resource of the extra warmth that's radiating the end of Neptune's interior. 

For Uranus, the models display that a grazing or oblique influence from an additional rocky object might explain the planet's tilt, and the odd orbital properties the its moons. Researchers think the moons that Uranus likely developed out the a disk of debris that was once approximately the planet, and the brand-new models display that together a debris disk might have to be the byproduct of a glancing blow.

It’s exciting that the new models display support for collision hypotheses, Reinhardt composed in one email. However he additionally notes they still have actually plenty much more work to carry out for this project. Because that example, the researchers still need to attach these potential collisions come simulations the the solar system’s formation, as well as model exactly how the planet's insides would certainly have developed over much longer periods that time. 

“Understanding the formation and also evolution the Uranus and also Neptune is not just a absent puzzle piece when trying understand how ‘our’ planets formed," Reinhardt wrote, "but also provides a far better understanding that the formation of the plenty of observed exoplanets in this massive regime."

The researchers presented your findings in Monthly Notices that the Royal expensive Society.