Q: Is Sen. Ted Cruz, that was born in Canada, standard to be the U.S. President?A: many likely. The legal agreement is that Cruz qualifies due to the fact that he to be born to a U.S. Citizen living abroad, making him a U.S. Citizens at birth.

You are watching: How can ted cruz be president

FULL QUESTION

Is Ted Cruz default to operation for president based upon the fact he was born in Canada however his mother was American? specifically what does the Constitution and our other regulations say around this?

FULL ANSWER

Sen. Ted Cruz announced on march 23 that he will seek the Republican nomination to be chairman of the United claims in 2016. But, as part readers were quick to suggest out, Cruz no born in the U.S. His birth certificate reflects he was born in Calgary, Alberta, top top Dec. 22, 1970.

The U.S. Constitution requires a chairman to it is in a “natural born Citizen.”

Article II, ar 1: No Person other than a organic born Citizen, or a citizen of the unified States, at the moment of the fostering of this Constitution, shall be eligible come the Office the President; neither shall any type of Person be eligible to the Office who shall not have attained come the period of thirty five Years, and also been fourteen year a Resident within the united States.

That should disqualify him from being president, right? no so fast.

Cruz, who pertained to the U.S. At age 4, is a citizens by birth since his mommy was a U.S. Citizen when he was born. For that reason, legal scholar argue that he can likely it is in president.

In 2013, sarah Helene Duggin, a Catholic University legislation professor, wrote: “There is a solid argument the anyone who acquires United claims citizenship in ~ birth, whether by virtue that the 14th amendment or by procedure of commonwealth statute, qualifies as natural born.”

The nonpartisan congressional Research service reached a comparable conclusion in 2011.

CRS, Nov. 14, 2011: The weight of legal and also historical authority shows that the term “natural born” citizens would average a human being who is entitled to U.S. Citizenship “by birth” or “at birth,” either by being born “in” the joined States and under that jurisdiction, even those born to alien parents; by gift born overseas to U.S. Citizen-parents; or by being born in other cases meeting legal requirements for U.S. Citizenship “at birth.” together term, however, would certainly not incorporate a human who was no a U.S. Citizen by bear or in ~ birth, and who was hence born one “alien” required to go with the legal procedure of “naturalization” to come to be a U.S. Citizen.

And this month, Neal Katyal and also Paul Clement, two previous U.S. Solicitors general, creating for the Harvard legislation Review, claimed that Cruz qualifies as a “natural born citizen.”

Katyal and Clement, march 11: all the sources routinely provided to analyze the Constitution confirm that the expression “natural born Citizen” has actually a particular meaning: namely, someone who was a U.S. Citizen at birth v no have to go v a citizens proceeding at some later on time. And also Congress has actually made equally clear from the time of the framing of the constitution to the present day that, topic to particular residency demands on the parents, who born come a U.S. Citizens parent typically becomes a U.S. Citizen without regard to whether the bear takes ar in Canada, the Canal Zone, or the continental united States.

Case closed? Cruz thinks so, together he called Fox News host Sean Hannity on march 23:

Cruz, in march 23: The facts space clear. Ns was born in Calgary. My parents — as a legitimate matter, my mom is an American citizen by birth. And also it’s been federal law for over 2 centuries that the son of one American citizens born abroad is a citizens by birth, a herbal born citizen.

Indeed, the Naturalization act of 1790, passed 3 years after the U.S. Constitution was written, stated that “the youngsters of citizens of the joined States, that may be born beyond sea, or out of the limits of the joined States, candlestick be taken into consideration as natural born citizens.”

But together the CRS discussed in the report, the 1790 law was superseded through the Naturalization act of 1795, which changed the language native “natural born citizens” to simply “citizens.”

So there is still part lingering uncertainty around Cruz’s eligibility. That’s since the supreme Court hasn’t rule on the meaning of “natural born citizen,” which the structure doesn’t define.

This is no the first time the a Republican presidential candidate faced such questions. As we have written before, john McCain, who was the Republican nominee in 2008, to be born come U.S. Citizens in the Panama Canal Zone, and Barry Goldwater, that was the party’s nominee in 1964, was born come U.S. Citizens in Arizona before it to be a state. George Romney, that was born to U.S. Citizens in Mexico, ran because that president in 1968, but did not success the nomination.

Even Duggin, who wrote in her 2013 write-up that “a scholarly agreement is arising … the anyone who acquires citizenship at bear is organic born for objectives of short article II,” acknowledges the the concern may no be settled.

“In the lack of a definitive supreme Court ruling — or a constitution amendment — the parameters the the clause stay uncertain,” she wrote.

— D’Angelo Gore

Sources

Gillman, Todd. “Dual citizenship may pose trouble if Ted Cruz looks for presidency.” Dallas Morning News. 18 Aug 2013.

U.S. Room of State. Acquisition of U.S. Citizenship by a son Born Abroad. Accessed 24 Mar 2015.

Duggin, sarah Helene. “Is Ted Cruz a natural-born citizens eligible to serve as president?” structure Daily. 28 Oct 2013.

Maskel, Jack. “Qualifications for President and also the ‘Natural Born’ Citizenship Eligibility Requirement.” Congressional research study Service. 14 Nov 2011.

Katyal, Neal and Clement, Paul. “On the meaning of ‘Natural Born Citizen.’ ” Harvard law Review. 11 Mar 2015.

U.S. Constitution. Post II, ar I.

Naturalization plot of 1790. 26 Mar 1790.

Naturalization plot of 1795. 29 january 1795.

Bank, Justin. “John McCain’s Presidential Eligibility.” buzzpatterson.com. 16 Jun 2008.

See more: High School Graduation Speeches By Teachers, High School Graduation Speeches

Hulse, Carl. “McCain’s Canal Zone bear Prompts Queries about Whether the Rules him Out.” brand-new York Times. 28 Feb 2008.