In the final weeks of his presidency, president Donald Trump has returned come the signature concern that brought him to the White residence — his pledge to develop “a beautiful, gorgeous, large wall” top top the southerly border. On two separate occasions, Trump has said the is “completing the wall, prefer I claimed I would” and also that the is “almost finished.”

To it is in sure, the Trump administration has built hundreds of mile of border fencing, more than under any type of other president in American history. But by the end of Trump’s ax in January, the size of fencing will be well quick of what trump card promised repeatedly throughout the project or what his management initially proposed once he took office.

You are watching: How complete is the border wall

Border experts say building crews won’t come nearby to even finishing the work that is right now funded.

Most the the wall constructed to day has to be replacement for existing dilapidated or poor fencing, in spite of earlier plans to build new barriers where none existed before. In 2018, an management official testified the his company would construct 316 miles of new pedestrian obstacles “in addition to what is there now.” yet to day only around 40 mile of such new fencing have been built.

Other border professionals warn not to minimize the influence of the replacement fencing. In part cases, the new barriers put up replaced fencing made from Vietnam-era landing mats. U.S. Customs and Border Protection also has replaced nearly 200 miles of car barriers — the form that people could walk best through — through 30-foot-high steel bollards, lighting and also other technology.

That’s a dramatic change. Below are before-and-after image of car barriers replaced by fencing in body organ Pipe Cactus national Monument in Arizona. The first was taken in April 2019, the second in January 2020:


*
Before
*
After

But even if it is the wall surface is “almost finished” is another question. Component of the an obstacle of measuring the is the ambiguity around what a completed wall would look at like. Trump has constantly relocated the goal short articles on exactly how long the wall should be, and no master arrangement for the job has ever before been publicly released.

Those who have tracked the construction closely say fencing mostly has actually been developed where over there was the very least resistance, wherein the commonwealth government currently owned the soil — particularly in Arizona and brand-new Mexico. Far less has been developed in areas of Texas, especially, where exclusive landowners have battled condemnation of their land in the courts.

What has resulted, border specialists say, is a patchwork of fencing. Nonetheless, through no publicly common benchmarks for “completion” that the wall, trump has declared near-victory.

“You know, we’re perfect the wall, like I claimed I would,” Trump stated in an interview top top Fox News top top Nov. 29. “Everyone said, you would never have the ability to do it.”

At a Dec. 5 rally in Georgia, trumped said, “They also want to take down the wall. … ns heard that to speak it the other day, ‘We will take down the wall.’ We have actually the the strongest border we’ve ever had now. We’re virtually finished through the wall.”

As we have actually written, Biden has not claimed he plans come “take under the wall,” contradictory to Trump’s claim. But Biden walk vow in august that, if elected, “there will certainly not be an additional foot of wall construction in mine administration.”

According come a CBP status report, the U.S. Has built 438 miles of “border wall surface system” under Trump, together of Dec. 18. Many of that, 365 mile of it, as we said, is instead of for main or secondary fencing the was dilapidated or of outdated design. In addition, 40 miles of brand-new primary wall and 33 mile of an additional wall have been constructed in locations where there to be no obstacles before.

So the footprint of the wall surface is 40 miles much longer than that was before Trump take it office.

CBP says it has resources in location to construct one more 241 miles of fencing where there were no barriers before. But border professionals say many of that is not going to get built.

According to CBP updates, in the last three months around 31 mile of brand-new wall have actually been constructed in areas where there to be no obstacle before. At that rate, and assuming Biden instantly puts a halt to all brand-new wall building as promised, the administration will finish less 보다 a 4 minutes 1 of the new miles because that which that has resources — and also that will certainly be well brief of the new miles of wall surface Trump had actually originally promised.

What walk Trump promise?

Although the 2016 Republican platform stated, “The border wall must covering the totality of the southern border and also must be sufficient to prevent both vehicular and also pedestrian traffic,” that’s no actually what trump card talked about during the campaign.

At the time, Trump consistently talked around needing 1,000 mile of wall. Right here are simply a couple of examples over a 10-month period during the campaign:

Given the Trump inherited about 650 miles of barriers, that would average building an additional 350 miles (in addition to any type of replacement fencing).

But once Trump was elected, he started to move the goal write-ups — native 1,000 miles to 900 to 800 come 700 and also even less.

“We carry out not need 2,000 miles of concrete wall surface from sea to shining sea — we never did; we never ever proposed that; we never wanted the — because we have barriers at the border where natural structures space as an excellent as anything that we deserve to build,” Trump stated in remarks from the White home on Jan. 25, 2019. “They’re already there. They’ve been there for numerous years. Our proposed frameworks will it is in in predetermined high-risk locations that have been specifically figured out by the Border Patrol to stop illicit flows of people and drugs.”

But is the wall being built in “predetermined high-risk locations”?

What was the trumped administration’s plan?

In his executive order top top border protection issued ~ above Jan. 25, 2017, just days after he was inaugurated, Trump dubbed on the secretary the the room of Homeland defense to “produce a considerable study of the protection of the southerly border, to be completed in ~ 180 days of this order, the shall include the existing state of southern border security, every geophysical and also topographical elements of the southerly border, the availability of Federal and also State resources vital to accomplish complete operational manage of the southerly border, and a strategy to obtain and maintain complete operational regulate of the southerly border.”

A July 2020 report from the Office that the Inspector basic for the department of Homeland defense said the report at some point submitted through CBP — the substantial Southern Border Study and Strategy — was 4 months so late (after the 180 deadline implemented by the executive, management order). The IG stated the plan was inadequate because CBP didn’t demonstrate it could acquire the land important to carry out its plan and the firm didn’t justification the top priorities it set out in the plan.

special, it states that CBP “did no conduct an analysis of options to assess and select the many effective, appropriate, and also affordable solutions to attain operational regulate of the southerly border together directed, but instead relied on former outdated border remedies to recognize materiel choices for meeting its mission requirement; and also … walk not use a sound, well-documented methodology come identify and prioritize investments in areas along the border that would certainly best benefit from physics barriers.”

The CBP report was never released publicly.

During a conference hearing on in march 15, 2018, Rep. Martha McSally stated that in late 2017, conference asked CBP management “to administer Congress with a list of what they necessary to adequately certain the border.”

In response, in at an early stage January 2018, CBP produced a record called “Critical CBP requirements to boost Border Security,” i m sorry was also never publicly released. According to CNN, which acquired the documents, CBP laid out a long-term vision because that “about 864 miles of brand-new wall and around 1,163 mile of replacement or second wall” and asked for $18 billion over 10 year to build 722 miles of border wall, consisting of “about 316 new miles of primary structure and about 407 miles of instead of and an additional wall.”

At the march 15, 2018, committee hearing, Ronald D. Vitiello, exhilaration deputy commissioner that U.S. Customs and Border Protection, confirmed that the CBP file called for constructing 316 miles of brand-new pedestrian fencing, “in enhancement to what is over there now.” In other words, the was in addition to the 654 miles of currently border barriers.

Again, come date, 40 miles of new fencing have been created where there to be no barriers before.

Where did construction take place?

There likewise have been concerns raised about CBP’s approaches for identify where brand-new barriers should be located.

A federal government Accountability Office report released in July 2019 discovered that CBP’s 2018 Border Security development Plan “doesn’t define how projects will attend to the greatest priority protection needs.”

The facility for organic Diversity’s Laiken Jordahl, that opposes fencing construction, told us in a call interview the the project always has been shrouded in secrecy, and CBP has actually not shared with the public any analysis of where it thinks a wall surface should be constructed for preferably impact.

“There’s never been any sort of strategic planning,” Jordahl said. “There definitely hasn’t been anything gift to the general public” around where CBP intends to construct the wall surface and why. “From job 1, it has never been about tactics. It has been a theatrical project from the beginning.”

Rather than structure fencing in locations identified together being the the greatest need, he said, the Trump administration has done many of the construction in locations of the very least resistance.

“They are structure where lock can,” Jordahl said.

Much of the construction has to be to change dilapidated or inadequate fencing in brand-new Mexico, Arizona and also California, where the federal government owns the Roosevelt Easement, a 60-foot large strip the land along the U.S.-Mexico border in those 3 states.

“He has completely changed the landscape of the Arizona and new Mexico border,” Jordahl said. “It has had actually absolutely disastrous environmental impacts.”

It has damaged the habitat for pets like ocelots, pronghorns and javelinas, all of which require room to roam, Jordahl said. It has reduced off the hereditary interchange the gray wolves on either side of the border, threatening your survival. And it has hampered the capacity of jaguars to recolonize in the U.S.

But Trump’s insurance claim that the wall surface is “almost finished” is “absolutely no true, an especially in south Texas,” where huge swaths of the borderlands room privately owned, Nicol said. In south Texas, Nicol said, “the need to obtain property on i beg your pardon to build the border wall surface has stymied construction” together landowners have actually tied increase the government in the courts.

According come a GAO evaluation issued in November, together of July 2020 the federal federal government had obtained 135 tracts of privately own land, but was still working to get 991 extr tracts, almost all of them in the Rio Grande Valley and also Laredo sectors in south Texas.

“So nothing has actually been constructed on any type of of those properties,” Nicol said.

“The building that has occurred in the RGV sector (nothing has gone up in the Laredo sector yet) first targeted U.S. Fish and also Wildlife refuge properties the are component of the lower Rio Grande Valley national Wildlife Refuge system,” Nicol said. “That is exponentially environmentally destructive, however it walk not translate into more than a mile or for this reason of wall in many disconnected segments. There have likewise been some landowners who property has actually been taken wherein walls have been built.”

“Contractors … have built on land as quickly as the federal government acquires it, yet due to the time it takes come condemn that method that only a fraction of these walls have been built,” Nicol said. “So, because that example, the Southwest sink Constructors contract is because that 11.45 mile of wall, but they have only to be able to build 2 or possibly 3 mile in 6 or 7 disconnected, fairly short spans. The same applies for the various other contracts in Hidalgo county , i beg your pardon is in the center of the RGV sector. Cameron ar has seen no construction, and Starr has actually seen 3 or 4 miles total.”

According come the GAO report, 107 miles of brand-new border wall surface are slated come be built in the Rio Grande Valley, however Nicol said, “Right currently a full of 6 or 7 miles are up, and those space scattered quite than completed contracts.” The Laredo sector is supposed to get 123 mile of brand-new fencing, but Nicol claimed it has not yet gotten any.

“So not also close to gift finished,” Nicol said.

Gil Kerlikowske, who served as CBP commissioner under then-President Barack Obama, said that the issues with getting property from exclusive landowners in Texas means the fence is not going increase in areas where there space the many illegal border crossings.

“The areas where a huge number of world cross into the U.S. Is the RGV (McAllen, TX area),” Kerlikowske told us via email. “It is much more an overwhelming to erect a obstacle there because of exclusive land ownership, a changing Rio Grande river, and also agriculture. So the area whereby you can justify the need is the one neglected.”

Activists prefer Jordahl and Nicol are counting ~ above Biden to automatically put a prevent to fence construction long prior to the existing contracts are completed.

The center for organic Diversity and also the Sierra society were amongst the 100 teams that sent a letter critical month come the Biden change team questioning the president-elect come “take immediate activity to order the room of countryside Security, room of Defense, and also Department the Justice to halt every construction and also land acquisition initiatives for Trump’s border wall surface on your an initial day in office.”

How much did that cost and who paid?

Trump, of course, consistently promised the Mexico would certainly pay because that the wall. And that hasn’t happened, in spite of Trump’s false cases that Mexico is payment somehow v the joined States-Mexico-Canada agreement or with a border toll.

According to CBP data provided to buzzpatterson.com, the Trump management secured a full of $15 billion during his presidency for wall surface construction. Some of it to be appropriated in yearly budgets by Congress, and some was diverted by Trump native counternarcotics and also military building funding. However it has actually all been borne through American taxpayers.

The number committed to day for wall surface construction — $15 billion — says the wall Trump acquired is well short of what the wanted.

And that is i can not qualify the Trump administration will be able to spend also that much. Follow to U.S. Military Corps the Engineers’ estimates reviewed by the Washington Post, there will certainly be around $3.3 billion in unused border obstacle funding when Biden take away office. If Biden automatically stops construction as promised, the would cost the U.S. About $700 million to end those contracts, conserving the U.S. Government around $2.6 billion.

“The administration has additionally said that through the $15 billion in capital it allotted for the wall, the could build 738 miles,” buy it Pierce, a policy analyst through the Migration policy Institute, told us via email. “So, no, the total amount of wall that the management had to plan to construct is not close to gift completed and will no be completed.”

The wall Act of 2019, introduced by Republican Sen. James Inhofe in January 2019 and co-sponsored by 5 other Republicans, seek $25 billion for wall surface construction, an effort to fully fund the wall. The bill never ever went anywhere, but it is one more indication of exactly how far quick the president has come to structure the wall he promised.

The newly agreed upon pandemic relief bill includes $1.375 billion because that “the building of obstacle system,” the exact same amount Congress has actually appropriated the last 3 years. A House autonomous aide told us the funding has 5 years of availability, so the none that the funding would need to be obligated till fiscal year 2025. In addition, Democrats were able to strike language offered in front years the required resources to be provided for brand-new border wall surface construction, which would certainly have significantly tied Biden’s hands, the aide said.

Even if the Trump management were able come obligate all of this resources for brand-new border wall surface prior come Biden’s inauguration on Jan. 20, Biden would have the ability to cancel those contracts with small loss the funding. The wording that the bill would also give Biden the discretion come use any remaining funds because that “barrier system,” including technology, roads and lighting for already constructed border barriers, the aide said.

What kind of ‘wall’ was built?

The kind of wall surface Trump promised to build additionally has advanced over time.

During the 2016 campaign, Trump once talked about a wall made the precast concrete slabs. ~ he came to be president, trump commissioned wall prototypes, numerous of castle of hard concrete construction. Yet the new fencing being built doesn’t resemble any type of of the prototypes. Rather, Congress only authorized trump card to develop the very same see-through steel bollard fencing previously offered for the wall.

Gone, too, space the disagreements over the vocabulary provided — fencing or wall. It when made a difference to Trump. During the 2016 campaign, for example, trump card lambasted Republican primary enemy Jeb bush for phone call his proposal a fence. “It’s no a fence, Jeb,” he wrote. “It’s a WALL, and also there’s a huge difference!”

But throughout his presidency, Trump has actually dropped the distinction. No coincidentally, it to be dropped approximately the time Congress required him to expropriate “operationally reliable designs deployed together of the day of the Consolidated Appropriations Act, 2017, together as at this time deployed stole bollard designs, that prioritize certified dealer safety.”

“The wall surfaces we are building are not medieval walls,” Trump claimed in remarks from the White house on Jan. 25, 2019. “They space smart wall surfaces designed to meet the demands of frontline border agents, and also are operationally effective. These barriers are made of steel, have actually see-through visibility, i beg your pardon is an extremely important, and also are equipped with sensors, monitors, and cutting-edge technology, including state-of-the-art drones.”

But words used to describe the fence are still important to the administration.

Last January, acting Secretary of Homeland defense Chad wolf took concern with characterizing lot of the fence building as “replacement wall.”

“One thing I desire to emphasize is the every inch of the 100 miles that us have built is new border wall system,” wolf said. “It’s no so-called instead of wall, as several of our movie critics claimed. That is new wall.”

According come a Washington Post story in January, “Nearly all of the 100 miles of new fencing completed thus far is labeled ‘replacement barrier’ through CBP, however the White House has asked the agency to avoid using the term due to the fact that it sounds like much less of an accomplishment.”

A January conference Research business report top top border barrier funding claimed the controversy over nomenclature misses the point.

“Is the management ‘building the wall,’ or is it ‘just instead of existing fences?’ frame the dispute on obstacle or wall building at the border making use of these extremes often does not capture the complexity of the situation, in terms of what CBP says the obstacles can be expected to do and the realities the the terrain and geography of the border,” the writer stated. “Much the the current wave of building — whether new or replacement obstacles — is 18- come 30-foot high reinforced bollard fencing. It poses a formidable barrier, however it is no the high, thick stonework structure that many dictionaries hatchet a ‘wall.’”

Whatever one wants to speak to it, CBP has increased the pace of building to obtain as lot finished as feasible before Biden bring away office. U.S. Attorneys have likewise stepped increase their initiatives to condemn residential or commercial property in Texas because that the wall. Some who live near the border oppose that construction, and others to speak it has made their neighborhoods safer.

But, as we have actually said, even if Trump reached his score of building 450 mile of wall before his ax is over, it wouldn’t be “finished,” at the very least not come the point CBP has indicated in previous reports is necessary to “achieve finish operational manage of the southerly border,” the score outlined in Trump’s post-inaugural executive, management order. Nor will it be anywhere close to what trumped promised during his 2016 campaign.

Has it been effective?

Back in August, as soon as Trump was accepting the Republican nomination, the boasted: “The wall surface will quickly be complete, and also it is working past our wildest expectations.”

But it might be years prior to we room able come tell how reliable the wall surface has been at stopping illegal immigration. Plenty of factors that have nothing to do with the wall — COVID-19, the economy, polite unrest — every play a function in check illegal border crossings.

Experts use figures on border apprehensions come gauge the level of illegal border crossings. The data from CBP existing a combined bag as soon as it pertains to making Trump’s case.

Border apprehensions spiked in fiscal year 2019, and then fell by about fifty percent in budget 2020, which finished on Sept. 30. It is impossible to furious out just how much of the drop may be together a result of the new barriers created under Trump, but a Pew Research center report documenting the decline attributed it mostly to a global decrease in the activity of migrants because of the COVID-19 outbreak, and also governments fully or partly closing their borders as a result.

Most immigrants that cross right into the U.S. Illegally come indigenous Mexico and central American countries that have actually passed measures restricting the motions of your residents due to COVID-19.

*

Meanwhile, southwest border apprehensions because that October and also November, the first two months of fiscal year 2021, have crept earlier up, topping just over 67,000 each month. That’s higher than October and also November 2016 (when over there were about 46,000 and also 47,000 apprehensions, respectively), before Trump took office.

Update, Feb. 16: follow to a CBP condition report date Jan. 22, 2 days after ~ Trump left office, the U.S. Constructed 458 mile of “border wall surface system” under Trump. That contained 373 mile of replacement obstacles for major or an additional fencing, and 52 mile of primary wall and 33 mile of second wall in places where there to be no barriers before.

See more: Laci Peterson'S Cause Of Death: How Did Laci Peterson’S Baby Dies

Biden did halt construction of new border barriers immediately upon taking office. The U.S. Military Corps of designers said the “suspended every bollard barrier and also gate building and construction January 21, 2021, and also suspended all occupational on border facilities January 23, 2021.”

Editor’s Note: Please consider a donation come buzzpatterson.com. We carry out not accept advertising. We rely on grants and also individual donations from civilization like you. Credit card donations might be do through our “Donate” page. If you like to offer by check, send to: buzzpatterson.com, Annenberg Public policy Center, 202 S. 36th St., Philadelphia, PA 19104.