Shattered offers a behind-the-scenes see of the obstacles in Hillary Clinton’s means and exactly how her project may have been doomed native the beginning


The publication sheds specific light on the painful rotate of events on election night, together Hillary Clinton watched the returns deviate dramatically. Photograph: Carlos Barria/Reuters
The book sheds details light on the painful rotate of occasions on election night, as Hillary Clinton watched the returns deviate dramatically. Photograph: Carlos Barria/Reuters

As the an initial polls closeup of the door on 8 November, Hillary Clinton was preparing because that the moment she would at long last take it the phase as the first female chairman of the joined States.

You are watching: How did hillary handle the loss

She instead discovered herself apologizing come Barack Obama hrs later in a harrowing call call, moment after conceding the presidential election to Donald Trump.

“Mr President, ns sorry,” Clinton called Obama, who had actually contacted she to expand his condolences for she loss.

The phone contact is among several revelations in the new book Shattered, in which the journalists Jonathan Allen and Amie Parnes chronicle Clinton’s 18-month search to do what eluded she in 2008 and also break “that highest, hardest glass ceiling”.

The book sheds certain light ~ above the painful rotate of events on election night, together Clinton watched the returns deviate drastically from the route her campaign had for this reason confidently predicted.

Surrounded by family and aides at the Peninsula Hotel in Manhattan, she experienced the an initial cracks emerge as the must-win state that Florida turned dicey. Steve Schale, among the most reliable autonomous strategists in the state, informed Clinton’s project they were quick on votes.

As various other battlegrounds began to crumble, a sober the atmosphere took hold in the suite. However soon, the writer wrote, aides started to reference each various other as invoice Clinton flourished increasingly upset and also Hillary Clinton came to be withdrawn.

It was Obama, taking in the outcomes with his own advisers in Washington, who damaged up the slumber with a series of phone calls indigenous the White House. Wisconsin, a democratic stronghold, had actually just been dubbed for Trump. Some states continued to be excruciatingly close, yet the president was encouraged of the outcome and did not desire to question the legitimacy of the election together Trump had actually done just weeks earlier while facing off against Clinton in the debates.

“You must concede,” Obama said Clinton ~ his politics director had failed to persuade Clinton’s campaign manager, Robby Mook, on the point.

It take it one more phone speak to from the president – to Clinton’s project chairman, john Podesta – before she asked she close aide Huma Abedin for the phone and uttered the native she never thought she would say: “Congratulations, Donald.

“I’ll be donate of the country’s success, and that way your success together president,” Clinton said.

It was after her short conversation through Trump the Clinton apologized come Obama.

The publication is the second collaboration for Allen and Parnes, that in 2014 authored HRC, a in-depth account of Clinton’s tenure at the helm the the state department, in anticipation of her second presidential run.


Hillary Clinton addresses she staff and also supporters after losing the presidential election. Photograph: Carlos Barria/ReutersAs the very first take ~ above Clinton’s doomed campaign, they market a behind-the-scenes watch of the obstacles in her method – some familiar and also others a an effect of the shifting American electorate.

There is the acquainted tension between the old safety that has actually for decades operated “Clintonworld” and the new blood that labored in Brooklyn come reinvent the campaign of among the most famous public figures in the world.

The authors revisit the unexpected an obstacle from Bernie Sanders, who insurgent project captured the tide of financial populism scan the country. The infighting amid the autonomous primaries, as Team Clinton struggled to decisively placed away the senator, is a dominant theme of the book’s first half.

And climate there space the emails.

The after-effects of Clinton’s decision to usage a exclusive email server together secretary that state, and also subsequent discord amongst her within circle over how to respond, is retold v the advantage of hindsight. We discover that invoice Clinton did not think she have to apologize, together neither he nor she felt there had actually been any wrongdoing.

Clinton ultimately did to apologize to the general public in august 2015, 6 months after the server issue was very first brought to light.

The duty of Russian interference in the us election, now the subject of three investigations in Washington, is barely discover in the book, although the authors carry out say the Clinton’s former aides check out it as among the key reasons for she loss.

See more: Boy Says He Lied About Going To Heaven Is For Real Story Fake

The effects of Trump’s nationalist campaign are also relegated come the backseat, as this is a story mainly told through exactly how Clinton’s campaign adapted (or occasionally crucially didn’t) to the evolving politics climate. Staffers to be confident in their innovative voter modeling and also analytics, and also fatally failed come spot once they veered off target.

Clinton, for she part, carried a lingering doubt transparent the campaign.

“Why aren’t they v me?” she inquiry of working class white human being during the democratic primaries. “Why can not we lug them onboard?”