A German chronicler says Hitler to be making hateful comments around Jews prior to World battle I, suggesting that his anti-Semitic epiphany emerged years earlier than formerly thought


A young Adolf Hitler v his WWI comrades that the Bavarian make reservation Infantry Regiment 16, 1914-1918.Credit: German federal Archives


In 1994, a German woman in she late 80s, elegantly dressed and also wearing big gold-rimmed glasses, sat under for a videotaped interview come share she memories that Adolf Hitler together a young man. The future Führer had boarded in her family home in Munich because that over a year before volunteering in respectable 1914 come fight in the great War.

You are watching: How did hitler know who was jewish

In the interview in Munich, Elisabeth Grünbauer recalled the Hitler, if living with her family, had commented on his dislike that Jews, arguing that his anti-Semitic outlook had been cemented even prior to the war. Until now, the consensus amongst historians has been the it concerned the fore only after human being War I, as cutting board Weber, a German historian and Hitler biographer, note in a new article in The newspaper of Holocaust Research.

Grünbauer’s recollections can potentially aid fill in gaps in Hitler’s biography, making it feasible to date more precisely the timing of his advancement as an anti-Semite. Her testimony, to write Weber, was “evidence of anti-Semitic explanation by Hitler that predate any kind of other recognized reliable anti-Semitic expression by the by around six years.”

Historians usually date Hitler’s coming to be a radical hater that Jews come his tumultuous year in Munich following civilization War I, a duration when anti-Semitic sentiment raged in the city. Jews to be blamed because that the problems under i beg your pardon Germany agreed to end the war, and also for the financial ruin and also political upheaval the followed.

But according to Grünbauer, who died in 1999, the young Hitler “always complained about what was going top top in Austria, and, over all, that that he walk not desire to serve in the armed forces in Austria since Austria was too swamped with Jews . … that was among his recurring themes, the he said that Vienna and also Austria were so ‘verjudet’ the he had left the country and also was unwilling to fight in the war for Austria.” Hitler eventually was may be to sign up come fight because that Germany, also though the was no German-born.

She states these complaints came up repeatedly in Hitler’s conversations v her father, who, like her mother, showed up to have become close with the future tyrant. Hitler, she adds, “also said that the Jews to be exploiters, together they regulated Austria and the share exchange.”

Hitler’s comments describing Jews as exploiters were no something Grünbauer had actually heard personally – she to be 8 at the moment Hitler rented a room in her family’s home – however she says it was a sentiment clearly recounted to she by her parents.

Weber, a professor in ~ the college of Aberdeen and also author the “Hitler‘s very first War” and also “Becoming Hitler: The make of a Nazi,” defends Grünbauer’s credibility together a historical witness. He composed in his article, “The Pre-1914 origins of Hitler’s Anti-Semitism Revisited,” how, “her testimony should be read less as the an individual recollections that a young girl... Than as one account of the cumulative memories of her family about Hitler’s time through them. In fact, she interview... Really has two parts: one concentrating on points that her parents shared with her and also another in i beg your pardon she shares she own an individual recollections – for instance, of exactly how she and also her friends had tried to play harmless tip on Hitler.”

Weber came across the transcripts the the interview carried out by karl Hoeffkes, a German author and also collector of an individual accounts the the Nazi era, when a publisher and editor that knows, Wieland Giebel, mutual it v him this past July. The transcript was part of a manuscript the a forthcoming book based upon transcripts the interviews carried out by Hoeffkes that 1,500 people, among them perpetrators and also victims, who had direct accessibility to Hitler and also had likewise been interviewed by Hoeffkes. Giebel is editing and publishing the book. Hoeffkes had actually not previously shared the Grünbauer interview and transcript, i beg your pardon was maintained with his collection of various other interviews and research materials.

“As that turned out,” Weber told buzzpatterson.com in one email, “neither Wieland nor karl Hoeffkes had actually realized what the definition of the interview is. I suggested that i would try to explore the complete significance the the interview and also publish it front of the publishing of your book.”

Grünbauer’s recollections could help fill in gaps in Hitler’s biography, do it feasible to date an ext precisely the time of his advancement as one anti-Semite.

Grünbauer to be the daughter that Anna and also Joseph Popps, through whom Hitler lodged for 15-16 months before enlisting in the Bavarian military at the start of civilization War I. As evidence that Hitler came to be close v the family, Weber cites several letters and also postcards that he sent out the Popps, many of them native the prior in Belgium follow me the French border, the an initial two indigenous his time in training and also en course to the front in so late 1914 and early 1915.

“What provides Grünbauer’s statement significant is both the date of Hitler’s anti-Semitic remarks and also the disagreements used to justification them. Before the surfacing of Grünbauer’s interview, no reliable record had ever come to light relating to Hitler’s anti-Semitism before the summer of 1919,” Weber writes, “Crucially, the anti-Semitic explanation Hoeffkes tape-recorded predate civilization War I and also thus speak to into concern the accepted wisdom of exactly how Hitler turned into an anti-Semite. And they invite united state to revisit the question as to what happened to Hitler in his last years in Vienna.”

Hitler had actually moved to that city in 1908, at age 18, through a setup to to visit the art academy there, whereby he hoped to end up being a great artist. Instead, he was greeted through rejection and poverty.

In “Mein Kampf,” Hitler’s 1925 autobiographical manifesto, he writes the he came to be an anti-Semite prior to moving native Vienna to Munich – i beg your pardon this new evidence shows up to ago up. Nonetheless, Weber says that Hitler’s account of his anti-Jewish epiphany in ~ the end of world War I, as explained in “Mein Kampf,” shows up to be an ext a case of grandstanding and also presenting his own version of his political development as a “genius,” 보다 the truth. What we execute know, the historian says, is that Hitler’s views around Jews readjusted over time if he was in Vienna. Hitler writes that his politics awakening was sparked by hear in 1918 around the beginning of what would end up being known as the German Revolution, influenced by socialist ideas. Jews ranked amongst its leaders and also supporters. It was then, that wrote, the he chose to come to be a politician who can “save” Germany.

Open collection view
Thomas Weber.Credit: Rosie Goldsmith
Other chroniclers respond

Robert january van Pelt, a Holocaust historian and also professor at the college of Waterloo, in Ontario, claims Weber has actually raised an important question about the formation of Hitler’s ideology.

In an e-mail exchange with buzzpatterson.com, valve Pelt composed that “it appears increasingly clear that Hitler’s anti-Semitism, or far better anti-Semitisms (plural), evolved into a complex, many-layered phenomenon that contained earlier strata that embraced popular tropes around Jews as having actually too much influence, etc., come what turned the end to be the genocidal variation that did not focus on details Jews, or because that that issue the Jewish people, but on ‘the Jew’ – a nefarious ogre-like pestilence the somehow had obtained some human form.”

He listed that the latter form of Hitler’s anti-Semitism evolved around 1920 in an recurring dialogue with Alfred Rosenberg, a crucial ideologue that the Nazi Party, who he met in Munich and also who went on to come to be one the the masterminds the the Holocaust.

Moshe Zimmermann, emeritus professor of German background at the Hebrew college of Jerusalem, wrote an post for the newspaper of Holocaust study entitled “The Riddles that Conversion come Anti-Semitism” that was released as a solution to Weber’s article.

Zimmermann notes the historians and laypeople alike have end up being suspicious of new revelations and documents about Hitler, in certain those relating to Hitler as a youth and young man, both because there have actually been cases of fraud in the past and also because the the challenges of corroborating information.

See more: Guests On Face The Nation Today, Face The Nation With Margaret Brennan

In his article, however, he takes less problem with the validity the Grünbauer’s account about the time of Hitler’s anti-Semitic conversion, than v its significance, saying that what tho matters most was his post-war formulation that a radicalized, virulent anti-Semitism, despite the much more “garden variety” anti-Semitism the may have preceded it.

“We might assume beyond any kind of doubt that Hitler’s Viennese suffer acquainted him v anti-Semitism, and with radical options to the ‘Jewish problem.’ in ~ the same time,” Zimmerman writes, “we may also assume the anti-Semitism was no a dominant element in his Weltanschauung till after the war.”