At the 9/11 Memorial at brand-new York City’s rebuilt human being Trade Center, a increased adorns the edge of a mirroring pool. The effects of that day’s terrorist attacks are still gift felt two decades later.

You are watching: How has the world changed since 9/11


In acknowledgment of the 20th anniversary the the Sept. 11, 2001, terrorist attacks in the U.S., we asked UC Irvine scholars a single question: exactly how did 9/11 adjust America? they responded according to your expertise.

Roxane Cohen Silver, distinguished professor of emotional science, publicly health and also medicine, and Alison Holman, professor the nursing, on collective trauma

*
Roxane Cohen Silver

Although it’s a cliché come say “9/11 changed America,” through two decades of hindsight, it’s clean from the perspective of the field of psychological science that it’s true. The Sept. 11 terrorist attacks — i m sorry hijacked ours television display screens that Tuesday morning as civilization who search to do us injury hijacked 4 airplanes — recorded people’s fist throughout the days and also weeks the followed. It likewise ushered in 24/7 media attention to what has end up being known as a “collective trauma,” transmitting the horrible events of the day transparent the country and, indeed, transparent the human being in a issue of seconds.

While the occasions of 9/11 were tragic for those who lost a loved one, girlfriend or colleague, the assaults demonstrated that one go not need to know anyone who died that work to have actually been profoundly affected. We performed research amongst several thousands U.S. Citizens that started in the days complying with 9/11 and also continued for number of years. We found that those who watched plenty of hours of television in the main after 9/11 and/or watched the second plane fight the world Trade center or the structures fall live on television were much more likely to develop mental and physical health troubles in succeeding years —especially if they continued to worry around future terrorism.

*
Alison Holman

Since 9/11, mental scientists have increasingly well-known the important role that the media dram in transmitting neighborhood tragedies past directly affected communities. Moreover, due to the fact that 9/11, the media landscape has adjusted dramatically, amplifying what we experienced after the attacks. In addition to the development of social media, countless people also now carry smartphones equipped with powerful cameras that deserve to take graphic pictures or videos that tragedy that have the right to be soon distributed about the world. Repetitive exposure to these graphic and also disturbing images may exact a toll fee on those who see them, raising anxiety and also drawing world into a cycle of distress after ~ engaging news reports of succeeding tragedies.

The 9/11 strikes were tragic because that American residents, but they additionally taught us that the media have the right to broadcast distress together the news the covering.

Jan K. Brueckner, distinguished professor the economics, on travel

*
Jan Brueckner

After the terror attacks, the government implemented a short-lived nationwide shutdown the the airline industry, fearing additional attacks making use of commercial aircraft. Together airlines started flying again, lock did therefore under plenty of restrictions, many importantly the considerable passenger defense screening requirements of the Transportation defense Administration. The new screening process added time and inconvenience come air travel, and also —coupled v passenger fear of terrorism and other determinants — airline passenger traffic was drastically depressed complying with 9/11, taking 3 years to go back to its pre-9/11 level. In response to the revenue shock of 9/11 and to brand-new competition from low-cost carriers, the significant airlines behaved conservatively in adding back capacity as traffic returned, so the the carrier eventually available fewer seats to an ultimately larger number of passengers, causing fuller flights and today’s much less comfortable flying experience. Also though 9/11 is long past, the airline industry continues to operate in a climate of fear of terrorism from the air.

Erin Lockwood, assistant professor of politics science, on international policy

*
Erin Lockwood

The terrorist attacks were a transforming point in U.S. Politics, normalizing the use of military force versus state targets in an answer to an attack by nonstate gibbs on U.S. Civilians. Offered the stark polarization in U.S. National politics today, over there is, for some, a propensity to nostalgically psychic the immediate consequences of the assaults as one ephemeral minute of U.S. Unity. Yet we must also acknowledge and also mourn not only the lives lost in those attacks, but likewise that the strikes — and the U.S. Response — set in motion years of war, anti-Arab and also anti-Islamic bias and also violence, and a willingness come sacrifice military and civilian lives and civil liberties for the late of security. As we mark the tap the money of U.S. Forces from Afghanistan this month, it’s every too obvious that numerous of those trends continue to reverberate today.

David Kaye, clinical professor the law, on nationwide security

*
David Kaye

On the morning that 9/11, i evacuated mine office at the State Department, wherein I functioned as a lawyer, and also ended up surrounding at Memorial Bridge, watching in fear as the Pentagon burned. Personally, the job is a haze of tragedy and trauma and despair, together painful and also wrenching today as it to be then. In spite of my hopes for something better that could emerge, the attacks reinforced a cult of national security the the United says transformed into the torture of terror suspects, drone warfare, the intrusion of Iraq, Guantanamo Bay’s indefinite detentions, anti-Muslim discrimination at home and also the introduction of the modern surveillance state. American foreign and defense policy and also Washington’s reluctance come embrace fully global norms and also international legislation remain entwined with the reactions to 9/11. The advantage of nationwide security together an ideology and apologia remains among the most far-reaching legacies of that day, a function of American politics life that proceeds to restrict creativity and also a return to normalcy in American law and also policy.

Matthew Beckmann, associate professor of political science, ~ above the battle on terror

*
Matthew Beckmann

To understand the legacy of 9/11 is to define the heritage of George W. Bush. Because that after the deadliest terrorist attacks on U.S. Soil in our country history, American citizens and also lawmakers offered President Bush wide support and broader authority to wage the “war on terror” as he observed fit. What shrub imagined to be a brand-new world order, led by the United says — particularly by the chairman — where defense threats to be defeated and replaced v governments an ext like our own. “We walk forward with complete confidence in the eventual triumph of freedom,” he claimed in his second inaugural address. Twenty years after the attacks, having actually seen those lofty aspirations dashed in Afghanistan and also Iraq, disregarded in Guantanamo Bay and black website prisons, and also discounted even by ours staunchest allies, the biggest legacy the Sept. 11 for the United claims is that the “shining city top top a hill” has actually less luster and also a shorter reach.

David Theo Goldberg, professor of to compare literature, on the rise of false narratives

*
David Theo Goldberg

American politics has always encouraged fabrication. A tiny white lie here, a bigger one there. However, “fabricate often, fabricate big” seems to have come to be the meme because that the moment. The score is to have actually the basic public recall nothing else. “Stop the Steal.” “Critical race theory is a subversive Marxist plot.” “Mandated masks space a conspiratorial attack on fundamental individual liberty.” The strength of the false has come to be ubiquitous.

See more: How Do They Get Baby Carrots Grown? The Truth About Baby Carrots

The occasions of 9/11 lent themselves to make-believe. The exhilaration hadn’t yet cleared once conspiracies started to abound, native “weapons of massive destruction” to “the deep state.” the the Trump administration adopted this as its own playbook if insisting on “draining the swamp” required food preparation the rules. Alternate realities and also truths presume the status of the given: birtherism, Pizzagate, “vaccines kill,” “masks asphyxiate,” “the pandemic is biological warfare,” “Stop the Steal.” The ever-expanding fabrication and also “deepfaking” made the all too quick and also easy to refuse the actual and the evident. Fabrication had end up being the rule book of the game. Invention and inventedness, disruption and also innovation sustained the movement. The “truth” was, well, five so yesterday.